Reviews - Al Caratello
Reviews
9.5/10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
All reviews
9.5
Delicioua Food. No Pizza, but VERY delicious Pastas and Italien dishes.
9.5
Food and service were outstanding.
9.0
Very attentive service
10
Nouritture tress tress bonnee
10
An authentic Italian restaurant in the backstreets of Montmartre. Very busy (best to book), well looked after by the attentive staff and the food was excellent. A very enjoyable evening.
10
Server and owner we lovely. Food was absolutely delicious
10
Everyone was friendly and nice, cozy and romantic atmosphere. Was lovely, thank you!
10
Very good food, and attentive service
10
Have been visiting this restaurant for the last 8 years. This is one of the best Italian restaurants in Paris. I definitely recommend this restaurant.
2.0
A nightmare. I walked for blocks with my two-year-old, only to be turned away because they didn't have my reservation! They could not have cared less and were completely unhelpful. Never again!
10
Such a wonderful place! Ate there our first night in Paris and the staff were so incredibly kind. They made me a delicious pasta and chicken meal that wasn’t on the menu. They also spoke English which was an added bonus. I would highly recommend!!!
10
The food was some of the best I’ve had in my life! The staff made us feel like family!
10
all good
10
Delicious food and very nice service
10
Great food at very reasonable prices and a great ambience.
10
Homemade at a great price. Great service
9.5
Was a very nice place with very good food and lovely people
8.5
Excellent
10
Visited this restaurant this time last year while in Paris. The food is absolutely amazing the family makes you feel right at home. It an amazing experience.
10
Service was excellent delivered with great humour
10
The food in this beautiful, cozy and very special restaurant was extra delicious and the wine was extraordinary!!! People there just do their best to make you feel like home. They are all very kind and helpful. We had a great time and the best dinner during our staying in Paris. We shall visit it again next time we are around the city.
10
Lovely food, lovely atmosphere and very friendly and attentive staff. We booked for my 60th birthday and on leaving I was given a gift. I would highly recommend a visit to this beautiful restaurant.
10
Never fails to impress. Great Italian food and the staff are always very friendly. We book it every time we are in Paris.
10
Excellent service. Exquisite food. Very respectful staff and generous portions.
10
Simply fantastic. We ordered bruschetta, bresaola, arrabbiata and moules. Thank you Jay and the team for the most wonderful service. Will return the next time we visit Paris from the UK.
10
Good food
9.0
Food were amazing.
10
Great cozy setting. Great food and impeccable service. One of those places you discover and go back to each time you are here.
10
Very cozy place , good food and friendly service. Nice ambience.
9.5
The food was amazing - authentic Italian Excellent wine selection 💚
10
A hidden gem, its compact but there’s such a lovely atmosphere and food was delicious
10
We were going to Moulin Rouge and had reservations at 6. Since they had just opened, we were the first table there- but this place quickly filled up and had a line out the door. This is a wonderful intimate restaurant for all ages with both great food and service..
10
Highly recommend! Outstanding experience 💕
10
Perfect😊
10
Excellent! What a great find. The service was great, and the food was hearty, delicious and good quality.
2.0
Disappointing Experience Despite Reservation We had made a reservation several days in advance, but when we arrived, we were told to leave the restaurant and wait outside in the rain while the waitress checked the reservation list. During this time, other guests were allowed to enter freely, and people without reservations were even seated before us. When our reservation was finally found, we were told there was no space for us at the original (A) location. We were then sent to a second (B) location, and after that to a third (C) one. By that point, we no longer felt welcome or valued as customers. Out of politeness, we decided to stay and order something, but the overall experience was very disappointing. We had expected much better treatment, especially after taking the time to reserve in advance.
10
The owner greeted us, and gave us a small gift when we left. The food was excellent and the inside of the restaurant was charming. The limoncello along with the pasta was homemade. We will visit every time we are in Paris! Wonderful experience!
10
We went to Al Caratello Sept. 24,2025 and had a excellent experience at this restaurant. Great location in the theater district. The owner greeted us at the door and we were seated at a table in the centre of the room. From the beginning the service was excellent as the servers were very attentive to our needs - they took our drink orders and did not rush us on our meal selection. Overall the meals were excellent - we had a bruschetta appetizer, raviolli and gnocchi main dishes. Before leaving the owner treated us to lemoncello shots which was very much appreciated. Overall an excellent experience and I would highly recommend Al Caratello.
10
The owner greeted and seated us. He made sure we were comfortable and got us started before he went off to other in coming guests. Small but clean. Make a reservation because it fills up fast! The food snd drinks were outstanding, as were our waitresses. Very reasonably priced. After our meal the owner made a point of thanking my wife and I with hand shakes. The ambiance was great. Coming from America it was so refreshing to feel appreciated for spending your hard earned dollars. Wonderful experience. Thank you.
10
This place is an absolute gem! The food was unbelievable and reasonably priced. I’m Italian and I can’t believe I found my favorite Italian restaurant in Paris after visiting Italy last year. The owner, his wife, and staff were so welcoming.
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.