Reviews - Antico Ristorante Paoli
Reviews
9/10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
All reviews
10
All the boxes I gave 5 stars to! The food was exceptional and the service provided was excellent! Referred to by friends and grateful for the referral!
10
Excellent food and service
10
Great service.
10
Delicious food
9.0
Stunning restaurant and amazing food Took a while to be served but once had their attention they were very attentive
10
Amazing food and service
10
The restaurant had a wonderful atmosphere, the staff were exceptionally friendly, and above all, the food was truly outstanding.
10
I had an outstanding experience at this steak restaurant in Florence. The highlight of the evening was the Fiorentina steak, perfectly cooked, incredibly tender, and full of rich, authentic flavor. It was truly one of the best I’ve had. A special thank you to Michele, who provided exceptional service and guided us in selecting one of the best wines I’ve ever enjoyed in Florence. His recommendation elevated the entire dining experience and paired beautifully with the steak. The atmosphere, quality of the food, and level of service were all exceptional. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for an authentic and memorable steak experience in Florence. I will definitely be coming back.
7.5
The food and service were more ordinary than expected.
10
T bone steak was so juicy and tasty!
2.0
terrible!!The worst pasta in the world.
10
Wonderful!
9.5
My favorite restaurant in Florence I visit every time when I visit Florence
10
good!!
10
It was a honymoon , and we had a mazing moment, the food was wonderful , staffs were smiling welcoming and helpful .
10
Excellent service! Wonderful food!
6.0
There was nothing wrong, but there was also nothing remarkable. It was a satisfactory experience, just not excellent. No complaints.
10
My family all recommended the best steak.
8.0
good service
10
Our GPS sent us in circles but we finally found it and even though 30 minutes late, we were kindly seated. It was worth getting lost. We’re so glad we didn’t miss this gem in Firenze!
10
all good
2.5
This was one of the worst restaurants I’ve ever dined at. Terrible service and mediocre food - I can’t understand how it’s at 4.7 on Google. Disgraceful
10
Ammar good
7.5
I have a really high expectation before my visit because I was recommended by the owner of the hostel I stayed while I was in Florence for few days and with all of the good reviews on google. The atmosphere and vibes are good. Everyone was friendly and nice and feeling welcome at the restaurant; unfortunately, there was 2 big groups of guests dining at the same time and the food came in 45 mins after we ordered. If we did not ask for the food, I believe it would come in an hour. The food came in with warm temperature even the taste is good. But we were starving and tired. We didn't enjoy so much with the food.
10
Good experience
10
Extremely delicious food, excellent service and a very beautiful atmosphere. We enjoyed delicious carpaccio, a diverse and rich wine list, very tasty meat and amazing desserts.
10
On our first day in Florence, we made a reservation through an app and visited Ristorante Paoli — it was perfect in every way. We arrived 20 minutes earlier than our reserved time, and although the restaurant was already full, we were seated right away. The classic atmosphere and the neat yet energetic servers made us feel comfortable. Since it was our first visit, we might have felt a bit unsure, but thanks to the attentive and witty service of our waiter, Yasser, we had an absolutely wonderful experience. They even provided a Korean menu, and Yasser checked on us throughout the meal, which made everything very pleasant. The complimentary tiramisu at the end was the perfect finishing touch. We want to express our sincere gratitude once again to Paoli and to Yasser for offering our family—visiting Florence for the first time—such amazing service and delicious food. And with the Fork app discount applied, it truly couldn’t have been better.
2.0
Checked this place out for their steak based on a food critic as well as the high reviews only to be disappointed. Onion soup was bland. Ordered the T-bone as medium rare and it was completely rare. Served said it was medium rare. When asked for it to be cooked a little more, they brought it back out with half of the meat missing. Good thing I took a picture of the food prior to them taking it. Manager had to step in to get it sorted out. They also brought out the wrong beer at the start. It was corrected but the new one they brought was warm. When told about the issue, they brought a bucket of ice that took forever to “chill” the beer. Overall food is not worth the price. I don’t understand the high rating or the review it has.
10
Good menu nice service
10
Food and service
10
it was best of best in italy. staffs are really kind. and dishes are really wonderful.
6.0
It was fine. Overhyped. Felt like a machine and not a special gem.
5.0
The ambiance is very nice. Unfortunately our food took way too long and was cold . The ossobuco risotto entree had three tiny pieces of meat. Poorly presented entree. However they did not charge us for that entree .
10
I was satisfied with both the taste, price, atmosphere, and service. I would like to visit again
10
Service & food
10
so goot and taste wonderful
3.5
Relying on the tag line of being the oldest restuarant in Florence, and the appealing setting to for go quality food and service. Only negative on an amazing stay in Florence.
3.0
+1The space is amazing. The food was just okay and service was very lacking.
3.0
The fioretina steak is way too overpriced and it was really hard to swallow because of the steak have too many veins, the male manager at the bar doesn’t seem like to welcome tourist, when me and wife sat on the sofa outside, he gave us a very bad look for a few times.
4.0
Carpacchio had little flavor. Pasta was too salty, and Florentine steak was overcooked! So disappointing!
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.