Reviews - La Carbonata
Get up to 20% off
Conditions may apply
La Carbonata
Find a table
Book for free
Reviews
Food
Service
Ambience
9-10
7-8
5-6
3-4
1-2
What diners said about this restaurant:
Susan D. • 4 reviews
September 12, 2024
10/10Awesome food, wonderful wine with a table in the open door. Perfecto
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much see you soon at La carbonata Firenze
scott b. • 2 reviews
September 10, 2024
10/10Great service and great food. Loved the Bistek and Gnocchini. Service was excellent and the wine paired beautifully with our meals.
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much see you soon !
Paul H. • 3 reviews
August 31, 2024
10/10There is no way around the Chianina Bistecca! 🥩
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much we are happy that you had a good time after eating this wonderful Chianina
Diane M. • 28 reviews
August 17, 2024
9.5/10Food was great. We had steak, grilled veggies, roasted potatoes and zucchini flowers. Service was extremely prompt and friendly. Table was tiny, and we could have used more room. The chatter on the walkie talkie between the kitchen and the dining room was a little loud and annoying.
See 2 photos
La Carbonata • Owner
thank you very much we are sorry for the table a little too small the waiter proposed you a larger table to avoid this mix-up we apologize for the inconvenience for the communication between the kitchen and the dining room via radio! see you soon
Julien C. • 14 reviews
August 8, 2024
10/10This place offers great traditional Italian food. The gnocchi is incredible, and the meat dishes are fantastic. Great service by the mister! Overall, a wonderful dining experience that truly captures the essence of Italian cuisine. Highly recommended!
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much Julian see you soon !!
Tessa H. • 1 review
August 12, 2024
10/10The first evening in Florence was immediately unforgettable. We had such an amazing meal here! The local steak paired with a wine from Chianti—nothing could have been better. The waiter was very friendly and even had a limoncello with us. Since it was our first evening, we're a bit disappointed because no other restaurant will be able to meet this standard! ;) You definitely have to go here.
La Carbonata • Owner
thank you very much for the kind words we are very happy that you had a good time we did our best to welcome you to Florence so you don't forget our restaurant after this experience.. I hope to see you again soon to try new dishes
JIHWAN Y. • 1 review
August 6, 2024
9/10goood
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much!
Aymeric L. • 2 reviews
July 31, 2024
7.5/10We picked the place because of a 4.9 rating. Service was very friendly but the food was average, even disappointing and definitely not 4.9. The tomato from the calabrese was disappointing both in taste and preparation (left all the green center). The ragout was overcooked. Had it said 4.2 I would have concurred. 4.9 is misleading.
La Carbonata • Owner
bonjour monsieur, hier pendant le dîner je suis allé m'assurer que tout allait bien pendant votre dîner et votre réponse n'était que des compliments et les assiettes vides débarrassées parlaient... Je ne comprends pas cette critique en Italie le ragù doit cuisiner pendant un longue durée. la critique est acceptée mais il vaudrait mieux la faire immédiatement pendant le déjeuner ou le dîner, au revoir
Caryl R. • 2 reviews
July 17, 2024
9.5/10Very welcoming and the food was delicious
See photo
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much see you soon ..
Nina W. • 2 reviews
June 14, 2024
9.5/10Service was friendly and responsive. Food was very good. Atmosphere was good. The server recommended a great bottle of moderately priced wine. We had a wonderful time and recommend this restaurant!
La Carbonata • Owner
thank you very much Mrs Nina Wise we look forward to seeing you next time soon to try new dishes and other wines
Michael T. • 1 review
May 28, 2024
10/10we enjoyed everything about our visit to La Carbonata. The restaurant is beautiful and the the service was very good. we really enjoyed the steak Floretine.
See photo
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much Mr Michael see you soon la carbonata …
Kevin R. • 2 reviews
May 23, 2024
8.5/10Good food, great service. Beware the 20% off does not apply to items in the menu.
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much signor Kevin for the kind words, we are happy that you ate well in our restaurant! I'm sorry but when booking the fork warns the customer that the discount cannot be given on drinks and fixed menus
Xi F. • 2 reviews
May 14, 2024
10/10Perfect service! Very High-quality meals!!! All in all everything was perfect!
You Jin C. • 1 review
May 18, 2024
10/10It's been 20 years since I've been to Florence, Italy. I chose this restaurant because of the pork, which was an excellent choice. I've eaten a lot of beef in Korea as well, but the steak here was a really special and happy experience. I should try to visit this place again. Thank you to everyone in the restaurant.
See 4 photos
Markus C. • 3 reviews
May 17, 2024
9.5/10Great food, unfortunate to be in the middle of all the construction
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much.
Valentin D. • 2 reviews
May 11, 2024
10/10Great food & ambiance! The staff is also very friendly, helpful. We recommend it!!!
See photo
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much Valentin !
Boris M. • 4 reviews
May 10, 2024
9.5/10A very pleasant location for a dinner
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much ! See you soon
Russell B. • 1 review
April 23, 2024
10/10A significant number of reservations available even on Tuesday night in Florence usually isn’t a good sign, but don’t be fooled. This is a new restaurant and it’s located on a street under going significant construction. The food was tremendous. Service was excellent (and it was a waiter of one!). And the atmosphere was a great vibe. We had the spaghetti and truffle gnocchi, and the 2-person Fiorentina steak. Incredible. All of it. For dessert they served a creative and delicious take on tiramisu and a light yogurt and mascarpone dish with raspberries and little cookies. Decadent, both of them. Can’t wait to recommend this place to other back home in USA. Gracie!!
See 2 photos
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you for everything Mr Russell Burton for the compliments, we are happy that you had a good time in our restaurant. We are also waiting for the end of the street works to make our restaurant busier. I hope to see you again soon with us!
Lou Ann L. • 1 review
April 21, 2024
10/10We totally enjoyed this authentic Italian restaurant. The food, wine and service were the best. The ambiance was quiet even though it is in a busy street. Lots of construction going on in the street but don’t let that stop you from enjoying this wonderful restaurant.Gratzie!!
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much for your kind words ladies lazzarini we are happy that you ate and drank very well in our restaurant we look forward to seeing you soon to try new dishes. see you soon thank you very much
Mathieu K. • 6 reviews
March 19, 2024
8.5/10We had a very nice service from the staff. The food was great, good portion and very tasty food. We enjoyed specifically the carpaccio and the parmigiana! Very nice discovery!
La Carbonata • Owner
Thank you very much Mathieu kodsi see you soon!!!
Brian M. • 3 reviews
March 14, 2024
9.5/10Found the restaurant on TheFork and thought we would try. Food was very good and fresh. Ambience was very pleasant with nice American tunes being played. Waiter was very nice throughout the entire experience. Would highly recommend!
La Carbonata • Owner
thank you so much Bryan I'm happy that you had a good time I hope to see you again soon in our restaurant to try new things…
Silvano D. • 76 reviews
January 28, 2024
8.5/10Very good food. Friendly and professional staff.
Heeyeon K. • 1 review
January 10, 2024
10/10Very nice! Very delicious! Very kind!
Stanley B. • 36 reviews
December 31, 2023
10/10Excellent service with innovative cuisine in a great a lot location. Highly recommend!!
Tara M. • 3 reviews
December 14, 2023
7/10Last night in Florence. We have been 5 times to Florence so have eaten at many restaurants. We were the only ones there so it was a bit strange. Food was fine nothing special more expensive than most. Would not return
Michelle S. • 1 review
November 11, 2023
10/10Every time I think I’m not going to eat a better meal in Italy, I have another one! I did the price fix menu, and it was fabulous. The attention to detail and the interesting recipes were spectacular! Not touristy and did not disappoint!
See 2 photos
Tripadvisor reviews
51 Tripadvisor Reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.