Reviews - Oltremare
Reviews
9.9of 10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
Tony J. • 1 review
June 26, 2025
10/10
What a wonderful evening! We had the greatest service. Phenomenal food tasting and ambiance was on point. Would recommend this place a hundred times over
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Jordan, thank you for the wonderful review and we are very honored that you have chosen our restaurant. It was a real pleasure for us to meet you, I hope to see you again. A big hug to you and your wonderful family. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff
Maya K. • 1 review
June 25, 2025
10/10The meal was beautiful, the service kind, knowledgeable, and generous. We were celebrating our daughter’s 17th birthday and could not have asked for a better experience. Thank you for such a special memory.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs. Maya, thank you for the wonderful review and we are very honored that you have chosen our restaurant to celebrate such an important event for your family. It was a real pleasure for us to meet you, I sincerely hope to see you again. A big hug to all of you. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff
Ruth I. • 1 review
June 4, 2025
10/10
Excellent service, food was great. Definitely I will recommend this restaurant.Servers are attentive and friendly.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs. Ipsen, thank you for your kind review, I hope to see you again soon. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff.
Ashley S. • 1 review
May 29, 2025
10/10Everything was wonderful and delicious!! Best meal I've had in a while.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs. Ashley, thank you for reviewing us. I hope to see you again soon. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato &Oltremare Staff.
Fabrice P. • 2 reviews
May 29, 2025
10/10A memorable experience. The chief is so talented and generous. The food is really excellent! Would deserve a Michelin star. The service is perfect. The venue is beautiful and warm. The view over the Maiori bay and surroundings is stunning. I can’t find words to express the wonderful and unique evening that we spent. Many thanks.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr.Persichetti , Thank you for reviewing us, I am very pleased to know that we have met your expectations, I hope to see you again soon, a big hug from all of us. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff.
Claire M. • 1 review
May 25, 2025
10/10
Hats off to the chef and his fabulous team. The food, staff and setting were exceptional and very reasonably priced. A true gem on the maiori coastline, worth every penny. We have dined at a fair few Michelin restaurants and this has exceeded many of them.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. McFadden, thank you for reviewing us, it is a real pleasure for us to know that we have met your expectations, I hope to see you again soon. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff
Peter M. • 2 reviews
May 20, 2025
10/10An exceptional dinner, in an exceptional setting, with a wonderful staff creating and serving dinner at the highest level. High marks to chef Crisci for dishes that were creative, interesting and most importantly delicious, paired superbly with wonderful local wines, in a beautiful setting. Fantastic job done by everyone involved.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Mesrobian, thank you for the wonderful review also from the chef Alfonso Crisci, we look forward to seeing you soon. Thanks again Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff.
Matteo R. • 1 review
May 15, 2025
10/10
This place is honestly out of this world, me and my partner had one of the best cuisine experiences of our lives. Enzo was amazing and looked after us incredibly well, he couldn’t have done more for us! He selected the most perfect complimenting wine to our dinner selections and made it extra special for us. The waitresses also were amazing and looked after us perfectly the whole time. The food was absolutely sensational and a true testimony to Italian food. 10/10
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Rizzo, thank you for the wonderful review, we look forward to seeing you in June with your entire family. Thanks, see you soon Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff.
Steve H. • 1 review
May 17, 2025
10/10One of the best meals I have ever had. Delicious food, an incredible view and some of the best front of house and waiting staff I have been served by. We came on a Saturday for lunch and it was quiet, but that just made for a more impeccable and personable service.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Herrex. Thank you for the wonderful review, I was very pleased that you were guided by our advice and that you appreciated everything that Oltremare does on a daily basis. It was a real pleasure to have you as our welcome guests, I hope to see you again. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff.
Alexis B. • 1 review
May 11, 2025
10/10Vincenzo and his team were very attentive and provided an unforgettable Mother’s Day dining experience for our family! The food was exquisite and the wine selections were exceptional. While we didn’t have the pairing menu, our plethora of amuse bouche options provided made us feel as if we had selected the tasting menu. Hats off to the Oltremare team and if you find yourself in Maiori, it’s a must. All tables have a beautiful sea view, so you won’t be disappointed!
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Alexis, thank you for the wonderful review, it was a pleasure to have you as our welcome guests and I was very pleased to be part of the first visit to Italy of your wonderful mother. I hope to see you again soon. Thank you Vincenzo D’Amato &staff Oltremare
Ingeliese H. • 1 review
May 1, 2025
10/10We were warmly welcomed by excellent hosts. The service was great and matched the exceptional quality of the food. The food was excellent, with some wonderful surprises and a top wine recommendation.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Guest, thank you for the wonderful review, we look forward to seeing you. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff.
Dario C. • 1 review
April 19, 2025
10/10
The visit at the restaurant was an incredible success and a wonderful journey through a particular taste of the products of the Campania region. The exceptional combination of delicious food and wine paring and the impeccable service and dedication to every details made the entire experience to our complete expectations. I would like to express my gratitude to the Chef Alfonso Crisci and team and to the restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato and team for the unforgettable and unique time spent in this beautiful restaurant facing the spectacular bay of Maiori in the heart of the Amalfi coast. Thank you!
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Cortellessa thank you for choosing us. It is a true pleasure to have had you as our guests, and we are happy to have met your expectations. We look forward to welcoming you again in the future. Thank you very much. Restaurant Manager Enzo Damato & Staff Oltremare.
Sophia L. • 2 reviews
April 11, 2025
10/10It was an incredible experience dining at Oltremare. I felt very welcome the second I stepped into the restaurant. The staff was waiting for me with open arms and wide smiles. The sommelier even mentioned he was just waiting for my party. The atmosphere is very conducive to fine dining - the right type of music played at a volume low but yet discernable. I loved loved loved the food, the presentation and the pace of each dish served. It takes a level of art to make a fish dish with leaves layered between layers of fish — yum and unforgettable taste. I dined at the Torre Normandie next door the evening before and I have to say Oltre Mare is a far better place in term of services, the taste of the food and ambience. I will return to Oltre Mare when I am next in Amalfi but i will skip Torre Normandie.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs. Lee, thank you for the wonderful review, we are very pleased that you were well with us, we look forward to seeing you soon. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D'Amato
Anne R. • 4 reviews
October 30, 2024
10/10Excellent food and service, wine paring was outstanding
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs. Rethmann, thank you for preferring us, we are glad that everything was to your liking. Thank you for the wonderful review, I am still waiting for you to spend a pleasant evening with us. Maitre Vincenzo D'Amato & Staff Oltremare
Andres G. • 1 review
October 23, 2024
10/10
The team there went above and beyond and their hospitality. The food was outstanding, and the service was impeccable. Definitely worth more than One Michelin star
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Gomez, Thank you for choosing our restaurant! We are delighted that you had a wonderful evening with us. It is truly a pleasure and an honor to host guests as kind and personable as yourself. We look forward to welcoming you again with the greatest pleasure. Thank you once again. Warm regards, Vincenzo D’Amato &Syaff Oltremare
Grace T. • 1 review
October 26, 2024
10/10
+2Amazing food served by fabulous staff. A really memorable experience of culinary expertise. Highly recommended.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs. Thompson thank you for choosing us. I am truly pleased that everything was to your liking. I appreciate your wonderful review, and we look forward to welcoming you back with great pleasure. Maître Vincenzo D’Amato & the Oltremare staff
Mitch P. • 1 review
October 22, 2024
10/10
+7Give Oltremare a Michelin star ASAP! Service, impeccable. Menu, cohesive and delightful. Wine pairings, well-thought out and a story behind each. Of the entire evening, there was a single wine pairing that was slightly off, but my wife is close to being a Somm herself so that’s really splitting hairs. 10/10. Tell them the bourbon lover from KY sent you!
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Pangallo, thank you very much for the wonderful review, you used words that touched me a lot, thank you and I hug you with affection. Vincenzo D’Amato & Oltremare staff.
QING J. • 1 review
October 3, 2024
8.5/10the food and ambience is so good here, but the set just made me too full ;)
Oda I. • 1 review
October 4, 2024
10/10It was a great experience. The food was amazing and the service was excellent. The view over maiori was spectacular.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr Isaksen Thank you for preferring us and we look forward to seeing you with real pleasure. Restaurant Manager. Vincenzo D'Amato & staff Oltremare
Miriam Lizeth M. • 1 review
September 29, 2024
10/10Amazing experience
Oltremare • Owner
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR REVIEWING US, I AM VERY HAPPY THAT EVERYTHING WAS TO YOUR LIKING, I AM STILL WAITING FOR YOU WITH REAL PLEASURE BEST REGARDS VINCENZO D'AMATO &OLTREMARE STAFF
Marco V. • 1 review
October 3, 2024
10/10The food was outstanding, the dishes were extremely creative, the combination of flavors was fantastic and the presentation and the service were excellent.
Oltremare • Owner
MR VILLALOBOS THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR PREFERRING US, THANK YOU FOR THE WONDERFUL REVIEW, WE ARE WAITING FOR YOU AGAIN. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D'Amato &staff Oltremare
Sean M. • 2 reviews
September 29, 2024
10/10
+3Wow!! We had an incredible dinner at Oltremare - celebrating our wedding anniversary. The service was outstanding and each dish served was more delicious than the previous. If you get the opportunity you must try this restaurant, definitely our best dining experience on our trip to Italy - we highly recommend it! Grazie mille to everyone at Oltremare for making our evening so special!!!
Oltremare • Owner
Ecco la traduzione in inglese: “Thank you to Mr. Sean Marks for reviewing us. We are very pleased that he had a wonderful evening here at our Oltremare restaurant. We hope to see him again !!
Bianca M. • 1 review
September 18, 2024
10/10
+2The food was excellent, so well crafted. There were so many additions from the chef that made the meal even more special. The staff was so attentive and made it such a wonderful experience. If you’re into fine dining and want to taste something different while you’re in this area this is the place to go!
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mrs.Bianca Marcazzo, We sincerely thank you for choosing Oltremare Restaurant. It was a true pleasure having you as our guest, and we hope to welcome you again in the future.
Edward L. • 1 review
September 13, 2024
10/10
Wow! What a night at Oltremare. It was our engagement dinner and we couldn't have picked a more special meal. Enzo and the team were clinical and super warm hosting us and the food was ridiculously good! We had the Vegetarian taster which is, on paper 5 courses but with a spread of unique breads, a pre starter and a pre desert, it ended up being 8 courses and we were stuffed. The wine pairing of local, amazing Amalfi wines topped of a fantastic occasion. Big thank you to the team.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Edward Thank you so much for your kind review and for choosing our restaurant. We are delighted to have had the pleasure of serving you. If you ever decide to get married in Italy, we warmly invite you to consider our Hotel Club2 Torri. It’s a renowned venue for weddings, known for its charm and exceptional service. Wishing you all the best and hoping to welcome you again soon. Warm regards, [ Enzo D’Amato & Oltremare Staff
Jennifer P. • 1 review
September 6, 2024
10/10
Oltremare was the most incredible experience we had on the Amalfi coast. It’s location in maiori has the most breathtaking views of the coast. The service was 10/10. The staff were extremely knowledgeable and welcoming, walked us through every step of the 6 course menu with matching wines. The menu itself was perfection. The detail of each course was outstanding, and the produce was fresh and local, and the dishes were innovative. Commendations to the staff and chef, we will definitely be coming back when next in the Amalfi coast.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Ms. Jennifer Piccoli, Thank you so much for choosing our Oltremare gourmet restaurant. We were truly delighted to have you as our guest, and it brings us great joy to know that you enjoyed your experience with us. We look forward to welcoming you again in the future and offering you another memorable culinary experience. Best regards, Vincenzo D’Amato
Eduardo G. • 4 reviews
August 23, 2024
10/10Wonderful experience! We had the tasting menu with just four plates with wine pairing. It was quite a lot of food with different tastes! Very good! Worth a Michelin recommendation!
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Mr. Gallo, thank you very much for choosing us, it was really kind of you to review us and we look forward to seeing you again on some other occasion. Best regards RESTAURANT MANAGER Vincenzo D’Amato
Victoria T. • 1 review
August 20, 2024
10/10We had the pleasure of dining at Ristorante Oltremare at the Hotel Due Torri last night. The view up the coast is breathtaking and the service was exceptional—attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about ensuring each guest has a memorable experience. We felt so welcome from the moment we arrived. The staff went above and beyond from the water list to recommending the perfect local wine. Each dish was a work of art, showcasing the chef's exceptional skill and imaginative flair. The highlight of the evening was the lamb, cooked to perfection in a Kamado Joe charcoal BBQ! The smoky flavor from the charcoal added a unique depth to the tender, succulent lamb, making it truly outstanding. We would highly recommend Ristorante Oltremare to anyone who appreciates modern fine dining and impeccable service. It was a truly exceptional experience and one of the best meals we have ever had.
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Victoria, thank you for the detailed and flattering review, it was a great pleasure for us to host you and we hope to do it again, warm greetings, Thank you for everything. Vincenzo D’Amato RESTAURANT MANAGER
Matthew B. • 1 review
July 26, 2024
10/10
WOW! What an absolutely amazing experience. I can tell you without a doubt this was one of the best restaurants I have ever been to. We arrived for my partner’s birthday and were immediately greeted by the warm manager and staff. The views of the sunset over the Amalfi coast were unbelievable. We sat outside and it was surreal. The service felt like a 3-star Michelin restaurant. The waiters were friendly and helpful while still maintaining an extremely high level of professionalism, especially, the sommelier and our server, Antotella. This was the best meal I have had in my two weeks in Italy. We dined at Torre Normana the other night which was good, but absolutely nothing compared to Oltremare, in quality of ingredients, creativity, service, and views, and I hope more people find this place. If you find yourself in Maiori or anywhere near it, I urge you to visit. Thank you for an amazing night!!!
Oltremare • Owner
very kind Matthew thank you for choosing us and I am very happy to have given you a pleasant evening, thank you so much for everything and I hope to see you again soon. a big hug
Lama W. • 1 review
June 29, 2024
10/10Amazing food, staff are very professional and kind. The view is stunning. One of the best fine dining experience 👌
Oltremare • Owner
Dear Guest, thank you for the wonderful review. We are waiting for you with real pleasure. Restaurant Manager Vincenzo D’Amato
Debra V. • 1 review
October 4, 2023
7/10The staff were very helpful and knowledgeable but as we were only 2 people out of four dining there there was very little ambiance
Riky C. • 2 reviews
September 24, 2023
10/10Amazing food and service, so unique. It's not only food, it's a culturel experience.
Jessica P. • 1 review
August 30, 2023
10/10Fantastic dinner, wonderful service, beautiful view. They brought out many welcome surprises. Had an amazing time.
Karl s. • 2 reviews
July 29, 2023
10/10
Amazing food. Great ambiance and service. Well worth the visit!
Miriam L. • 1 review
July 21, 2023
10/10Fantastic food and wine. And the staff was amazing!
David B. • 1 review
June 30, 2023
5.5/10Acknowledge if clients are celebrating an event like anniversary. Be somewhat flexible on menu, if something Is offered on vegetarian menu why can’t you get something separately off that menu? If you commit to supporting client in getting taxi back home follow on that commitment. Last most importantly the portion for fish was embarrassingly small. Even when we asked is this it we were told yup this is it. If your only criteria is good view this is place for you. Seriously It truly is great view. Most should expect more and with small numbers in attendance in prime summer season it appears reputation precedes itself. Hoping these comments help inform how to be better and customer focused.
Daniel D. • 3 reviews
June 24, 2023
10/10Beautiful views, nice people, good food - worth trying. We celebrated our anniversary and they made us feel special, even though we were a little tired after the drive from Sorento.
Guðrún R. • 14 reviews
June 21, 2023
10/10Perfect experience after a perfect visit to Almalfi ????
Khilen S. • 2 reviews
May 14, 2023
10/10
+2The food was amazing. Vegetarian menu was super, accommodated all our dietary requirements. Also, excellentn service, attentive, knowledgable. Would highly recommend.
Giuseppe M. • 2 reviews
August 24, 2022
4/10on arrival it turned out that our table was not ready yet, although I had already reserved well in advance, once a table we stood next to a machine that made continuous noise. All courses were lukewarm in taste and not building up so everything tasted the same. For dessert I ordered the cheese selection, it consisted of only 3 different hard cheeses and 2 types of mustard. For a restaurant that wants to maintain certain requirements for its quality, I thought the restaurant did not meet that, I am disappointed.
Melanie S. • 18 reviews
July 31, 2022
7/10We did the chefs 5 course tasting menu. There were some genuine highs to the restaurant. The views were spectacular. One dish on particular, the soup stood out as a star. Unfortunately the experience as a whole was disappointing especially at the price point. The food on the whole was fine. Apart from the soup, it was good but not great. Beautifully plated but not worth the 300 euro price point for 2 people. Unfortunately, the service is where it really fell apart though. The restaurant is positioning itself as a fine dining restaurant with fine dining prices and there were just too many big mistakes. First, I was still halfway through the pasta course -literally with the fork in my mouth - when the server came up and told us she was ready to serve our fish and took my plate away. I don’t think I’ve ever had that happen in a fine dining setting before - but I was willing to let it go. Then at the end of the meal the server brought out the petite fours., one plate for 2 people. Not 2 of each 1. Four different ones to share between 2 guests. My partner actually asked where the second plate was and the server replied “It’s fine, they’re complimentary” When he responded that it wasn’t fine, she said “that’s ok.”Then later came back and said it was the chefs fault not hers and no one had ever complained about having to share one plate before. Then before leaving the met came by our table with a selection of 3 digestives and 4 glasses. 2 people, 3 digestives, four glasses. I guess you’re supposed to choose which one you don’t want? I know this is a really harsh review and I want to mitigate it by saying we had a great time. The views were spectacular. The food was mostly not memorable, but good. And the soup was a star. But given the price point, it was disappointing. Had the price point been 33% lower and the service been average I probably would have rated this restaurant highly.
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.