Reviews - Osteria i 4 gatti
Reviews
9.1of 10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
Gabe K. • 1 review
October 6, 2025
10/10Food was delicious and the service was top notch
Laura R. • 17 reviews
September 20, 2025
7.5/10Excellent food but the waitresses seem not to be happy to work there so the service is the minimum we could expert, not more. There were a lot of noice due to american people speaking very load and we even could not hear out own conversation.
Osteria i 4 gatti • Owner
Buongiorno signora.. le ragazze in sala non avevano solo il vostro tavolo da controllare. Per l'inglese facciamo del nostro meglio e per la gente che parlava ad alta voce l'abbiamo fatto presente ai diretti interessati ma sicuramente non possiamo tagliargli la lingua!!! Buona giornata!
Stephen W. • 3 reviews
September 16, 2025
10/10Excellent food and good service
Elizabeth M. • 5 reviews
September 17, 2025
5/10Passive aggressive signs absolutely everywhere was quite unpleasant and unnecessary. The food was average
Osteria i 4 gatti • Owner
I cartelli che lei definisce " passivi aggressivi" che ha trovato all'interno del ristorante sono dovuti dalla presenza di persone molto MALEDUCATE. Comprendiamo la sua recensione se non ha mai lavorato nel nostro settore. Cordiali saluti. Lo staff 4 gatti!
Rebecca K. • 1 review
September 16, 2025
8/10We had a nice table outside. Service and food were good. Grilled chicken was excellent. Had been looking for a chicken dinner being gluten free.
Alona S. • 4 reviews
September 12, 2025
8/10pleasant balcony. Good pasta dishes.
Jeff R. • 3 reviews
September 1, 2025
9/10
We had an absolutely wonderful time at Osteria i 4 gatti. The welcome was warm and attentive, making me feel instantly comfortable. Every dish was prepared with care and passion—authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and beautiful presentation. The service was efficient without ever feeling rushed, and every wine recommendation perfectly complemented the food. The atmosphere is cozy and authentically Italian, the kind of place where you feel at home and want to return again and again. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who appreciates refined Italian cuisine and outstanding service. Bravo to the entire team!
Jody d. • 2 reviews
September 1, 2025
10/10Everything was perfect. Would return again if in the area.
Lou C. • 1 review
September 8, 2025
5.5/10We have been to the restaurant several times over the past five years but this was the first time that the service has been poor. We waited a long time from sitting down to having our order taken which I put down to not enough staff. There was one person taking orders, one person showing to tables and one delivering food. two of these people were almost running around the restaurant which is not only dangerous but doesn't look good to customers. about twenty minutes after finishing our main, which was very nice, we were asked if we wanted to see the desert menu and we said yes, ten minutes past and we asked one of the other staff members who brought menus 10 minutes later but nobody ever came to take our order so we eventually left having only had main course. The food was very good but the owners need to get more staff, it was very busy and a particularly frustrating night for us.
Adam B. • 1 review
August 31, 2025
9/10We recommend this restaurant to anyone passing through San Gimignano. The experience seemed very authentic, and the waiter was very attentive and made some great recommendations for both food and wine. If possible, we recommend sitting outside on the terrace as this offered a great atmosphere during sunset.
Pania S. • 2 reviews
August 26, 2025
9/10Visited for early dinner on the shaded terrace. The food was very good - lamb with gorgonzola, steak and rosemary oil, truffle carbonara, canneloni beans with sage, wild boar ragu and pasta. Loved it all. Not cheap though for 5 people 148E.
David M. • 2 reviews
August 22, 2025
10/10
Great food and good service!
Sebastiaan H. • 1 review
August 23, 2025
10/10
Had the best time with my wife, ambiance and view was amazing. Great service and excellent food for a good price. 10/10 would eat again
Sarah D. • 1 review
August 21, 2025
10/10Lovely food, attentive staff and beautiful terrace. A great spot
Ben B. • 14 reviews
August 20, 2025
2/10
The staff came across as rude, tired, and uninterested in their work. The restaurant is filled with unpleasant signs scolding customers with rules and regulations, which makes for a very unwelcoming atmosphere. People coming in for a nice lunch shouldn’t have to deal with that. The food was no better. The grilled lamb was overcooked and nearly inedible, served with overly salted roasted potatoes. The pasta was bland and completely forgettable. Unfortunately, in a tourist-heavy area the options can be limited, but I expected better given the ratings on TheFork. This place was a disappointment and not worth your time. Skip it and look elsewhere for a proper meal.
Osteria i 4 gatti • Owner
Buongiorno, sicuramente lo staff è stanco, ma non disinteressato al lavoro.. " I regolamenti " come dice lei, sono stati creati per la gente maleducata con cui abbiamo avuto esperienze maleducate. Ovunque si vada si seguono regole, non solo a casa propria. Si parla di gusto personale perché il cibo era buono!!!
Giorgia S. • 2 reviews
July 30, 2025
8.5/10la location
Grégory Z. • 9 reviews
July 28, 2025
10/10Excellent restaurant, great service and very friendly team, pretty terrasse and delicious food. Special mention for their wild boar specialties.
Αρσένης Σ. • 2 reviews
July 14, 2025
9/10Nice setup and food
Jonas K. • 12 reviews
July 15, 2025
9.5/10
Food was amazing, we had the carbonate with truffles, the ragu, the gnocchi and the sliced beef with truffles. Wine was also excellent. Food came quickly and the service was great
Brenten C. • 1 review
July 11, 2025
10/10Food and service was excellent
Andri D. • 1 review
July 8, 2025
10/10The service is so warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. Combined with a peaceful and charming atmosphere, it’s the perfect place to enjoy lunch or dinner. Every dish is crafted with fresh ingredients and rooted in traditional Tuscan recipes, resulting in authentic, beautifully balanced flavors. Highly recommended.
Andrew C. • 2 reviews
June 20, 2025
10/10Very nice food,good service and great ambiance.
Juulia K. • 2 reviews
June 18, 2025
10/10We enjoyed a great dinner, regardless of there not being four cats on site! ;) The restaurant is a little off the busier streets of S. Gimignano and the atmosphere is cozy. The drink and food were great value for money, and the staff was friendly and attentive.
Osteria i 4 gatti • Owner
Thank you so much!! 😍
Michael C. • 1 review
June 15, 2025
10/10The staff and their service was excellent. The food was prepared beautifully and with love.
Rainer K. • 102 reviews
June 15, 2025
8.5/10small osteria that gives you the chance of sitting outside with a small menu full of local cuisine that I enjoyed
Noel W. • 3 reviews
June 10, 2025
7.5/10This is a quaint restaurant inside the wall of San Gimignano. The menu has lots of options. The service was good and the ambiance fantastic. However, the food did not match the quality of the venue. The wild boar “stew” was just meat, and the beef dish seemed like it had been under a warmer for a while as it was dry. Could have been an isolated experience.
Marcos E. • 1 review
June 13, 2025
9/10Food was good, but north really outstanding.
ALEXANDRA C. • 14 reviews
June 12, 2025
10/10The city the food the service the cozy veranda. A hidden gem
Raphaelle B. • 5 reviews
June 11, 2025
10/10Lovely food on a beautiful terrace. The meat was cooked perfectly.
Alexandra B. • 7 reviews
May 29, 2025
10/10Lovely terrace, great food and friendly, helpful staff.
Hayley R. • 4 reviews
May 31, 2025
10/10
Everything was perfection! Best meal we had in San Gimignano, it’s a must!
KS M. • 1 review
May 27, 2025
9/10beautiful and peaceful terrace
Anna R. • 1 review
May 23, 2025
10/10Delicious food! We had the best lambchops ever! 🤗
Jelena D. • 2 reviews
May 13, 2025
10/10
A nice terrace with beautiful views, vibrant atmosphere full of Italian vibe and charm, excellent service and outstanding food.
Justin S. • 2 reviews
April 14, 2025
10/10Nice service and good food!
Anne M. • 1 review
April 7, 2025
8.5/10Lovely peaceful setting on the terrace. Had a big round table with lots of space. Efficient service. We had just 1 pasta dish. The truffle pasta was tasty but quite a small portion.
Paola Natalia M. • 1 review
November 22, 2024
10/10Food was delicious and the staff were lovely ..
Vincent r. • 13 reviews
October 29, 2024
10/10We are regular guests as this is a great place to eat. Interesting modern versions of Tuscan dishes, an excellent winelist snd great service. It was busy but everything went smooth. A must if you go to this part of Tuscany
Rhadames T. • 43 reviews
November 1, 2024
7.5/10We had a late lunch at Osteria 4 getting. The girls taking care of were really good. They offered prompt and courteous service. The food wasn't exciting as expected. Flavors were lacking. We enjoyed the outdoors seating in the terrace. Thank you!
Tom B. • 1 review
October 23, 2024
8/10Nice atmosphere, good food and pleasant staff.
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.