For restaurants
Help


Reviews - Trattoria Il Mare

Reviews

8.3/10

Very good
217 reviews
Ambience
7.6
Food
8.4
Service
8.6
Real experiences from real diners
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.

All reviews

  • Alex L.
    Alex L.3 months ago

    10

    +6

    Wow! If you ever wanted to go home to your Sicilian friends and eat, but you don't have any Sicilian friends, you should definitely go to Trattoria Il Mare! It is exactly the restaurant I was looking for. Less touristic, more local flavors and atmosphere. The food is absolutely delicious! Simple, tasty, incredibly good. In the beginning they gave me a couple of bruschette con pomodoro, on the house. Perfect balance between the tomatoes, olive oil and herbs. I tried the grilled sword fish, which was amazing! Definitely one of the best I've ever had. As a side dish, I chose the parmezan spinach, which was also very tasty and perfectly cooked. Desert(s): I had the inspiration of ordering citrus sorbet. My God, you have to try that one! I also tried the tiramisu, also very good. Drinks: Looking for the real local experience, I took the house wine, which paired perfectly with my meal. The staff was very friendly, always present and attentive.

  • Dan e.6 months ago

    7.5

    Excellent food good but not great service We sat outside but little curbside ambiance & lots of traffic

  • Marcin M.7 months ago

    6.0

    Food was rather bland and mediocer. Guanciale in my pasta was really not crispy and not cooked, and that is definitelly what you want in amatriciana. The staff was really doing what they can but i Think the place is undestaffed.

    Trattoria Il Mare

    Il guanciale dentro la salsa di pomodoro, inevitabilmente assorbirà il sugo e perde la croccantezza. Al contrario, nella carbonara non perde la croccantezza.

  • nigel h.10 months ago

    10

    Traditional, low key, friendly, great food, very good value, no frills - just what we wanted

  • Roberto K.10 months ago

    9.5

    The chef, Fabio, took our order and turned it to a masterpiece. We had seafood pasta, grilled swordfish and tagliatelle with fish and calamari. Everything was fresh and cooked to perfection. We were seated near the kitchen and witnessed how the whole crew worked meticulously. The food was a bit slow to come but we appreciate how excellent the food came out.

  • Max D.1 year ago

    8.0

    Very nice local food. Definitely worth a visit.

  • Rumen Y.
    Rumen Y.1 year ago

    10

    The food was authentic and simply perfect. The atmosphere of small family restaurant was really warming. I would recommend this place 10/10

  • Olivucci E.1 year ago

    10

    Quality, quantity, price and atmosphere. A real family run traditional Trattoria. Do not come here if you want to impress with fancy gourmet dishes. Come here only if you are interested in delicious Sicilia food, kind service and a cozy atmosphere. Will be back again and again.

  • Clair W.1 year ago

    7.5

    Delicious food!

  • Joana D.1 year ago

    9.0

    Great, really great service. The owner and his son are cooking, really adorable and happens not so often even in the family restaurants. The pasta for my daughter was a little bit too salted and they have offered to me, to bring me a new one. I have rejected their offer, but they surprised me with no paying for the pasta. Amazing, really!!! The rest of the food was very delicious, typical Sicilian, fresh fish and huge portion, the prices more than perfect 👌

  • Malcolm H.1 year ago

    7.5

    A nice lttle restaurant and the food was of good quality but the service was rather quick in that you had just finished one course and the next one arrived. Staff were very pleasant

  • Patrick D.1 year ago

    8.0

    This restaurant is rustic, but don't let that detract from the quality and quantity of the food they produce. This is not 'fine dining' but it most certainly is replenishment dining, if you've spent the day trekking on Mt. Etna. The staff were very friendly and helpful and, providing you are not fussy, this is a great trattoria.

  • Sara M.2 years ago

    2.0

    After 2 hours waiting in an almost empty restaurant we decided to live. We were extremly hungry. We wanted to pay the wine and beer we had and they expected us to pay the full meal we never got. The chef was screaming like crazy that he had a lot of work . SCARY.

  • Anssi R.
    Anssi R.2 years ago

    10

    Best food I’ve ever had. Take the 20e (for two) seafood antipasto. 8 plates of pure seafood bliss. The house wine was really good and cheaper than water.

  • Celia B.2 years ago

    10

    Wonderful food and service! Congratulations to everyone in the team, truly a memorable experience for us while in Sicily. Definitely recommended

  • Janet W.more than 2 years

    8.0

    We had a very enjoyable dinner at Il Mare, on a Tuesday evening at 7:30 pm. This is early by Italian standards, and the only reason why I marked the ambience down, as at that hour, it was impossible to judge. That aside, it’s an unpretentious restaurant that serves delicious seafood. We started with complimentary bruschette, followed by stuffed sardines, oven baked sea bream and mixed fried seafood, with grilled aubergines. Our server filleted the bream meticulously and it was beautifully cooked. The house white was pleasantly dry, and we finished off with an excellent home-made limoncello digestif. All this for under 60 Euro, which we thought was very good value.

  • Felyppe R.more than 2 years

    10

    Amazing italian traditional place. If you are looking for a proper Sicilian food experience not made for tourists, but for true Italians, you will love it!

    Trattoria Il Mare

    Thank you Sir, this is our mission!

  • András U.more than 2 years

    10

    It was amazing. The place is a small local restaurant with guest from the neighborhood. The food was fresh and super delicious, and the service was superb. I wish that I could visit this place more often. I really hope this place stays the same and I can come back somewhere in the future.

  • Martina a.
    Martina a.more than 2 years

    9.5

    The food was excellent, we had the 13 plates of antipasto, which was more than enough for two people! We also had an excellent pasta and the frittura was nice. I strongly recommand the place.

    Trattoria Il Mare

    Thank you Madame for your kindness. Hope to see you again to make you taste other of our special sicilian recipes!

Tripadvisor reviews

Tripadvisor
637 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

Book a table

For free

Are you a restaurant owner?

Register your Restaurant

Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible

Already a Client

Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.

Download our App

  • Download from the App Store
  • Get it on Google Play
  • About
  • Loyalty program
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Are you a restaurant?
  • Privacy and Cookies Statement
  • Frequently asked questions
  • We are hiring
  • MICHELIN Guide Partnership
  • Restaurant near me

© 2026 La FourchetteSAS - All rights reserved

Promotional offers are subject to conditions displayed on the restaurant’s page. Offers on alcoholic beverages are strictly reserved for adults. Alcohol abuse is dangerous for your health. Drink with moderation.