Reviews - Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939
Reviews
9.3of 10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
Elvin Z. • 1 review
February 25, 2026
10/10Great service great food, great drink.
Qiu X. • 1 review
February 18, 2026
10/10Absolutely worth visiting! Had an amazing time here！
Steven K. • 3 reviews
February 21, 2026
10/10The staff made us feel like we were part of the family. Several stopped by our table to check on us and offer suggestions. Definitely will be a return visit for us.
Stella T. • 4 reviews
February 17, 2026
10/10
Service staff were all so kind as to provide very detailed introduction of different kinds of T bone steak. I love their recommend of Chianina.
WENTING L. • 1 review
February 18, 2026
10/10
really good
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you. See you soon
Yonghyun K. • 4 reviews
February 15, 2026
10/10Good food and wonderful atmosphere
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you so much!
Hanna M. • 4 reviews
February 8, 2026
10/10Teasty restraunt
Jina C. • 1 review
February 9, 2026
10/10
+1Fiorentina steak wonderful! We had a good time :D
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you!
Sara P. • 17 reviews
January 30, 2026
9/10I had the peposo and the person I was with had yh stracotto. They were both very nice. The only thing the meat used for the peposo was at times a little dry. But the way it was cooked was excellent.
Kim C. • 1 review
January 29, 2026
10/10The hostess was quite helpful and very friendly. So was the wait staff. Mushroom Risotto was yummy and I enjoyed watching food be prepared through a big glass window.
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you so much! See you soon
Pei-Yu K. • 1 review
January 28, 2026
10/10Great:)
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank u
Jose Carlos F. • 18 reviews
January 24, 2026
8.5/10The staff Is outstanding. The food is good, specially for meat lovers.
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you ! See you soon
Steven C. • 2 reviews
January 16, 2026
10/10Very friendly and helpful staff Best steak I’ve ever had
yurui Q. • 1 review
January 20, 2026
10/10
the food is really surprising and delicious！and also the service is really good！i would come back agian when i back to Florence！
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you so much!
Wing Hei W. • 1 review
January 10, 2026
10/10Brilliant, would definitely go back
João Pedro c. • 1 review
January 18, 2026
8.5/10very good bisteca. Tiramisu 7/10.
XIYUAN L. • 3 reviews
January 14, 2026
10/10
Very delicious
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you!
christos s. • 1 review
January 1, 2026
8/10All good
Rye S. • 1 review
January 1, 2026
10/10
good good good everything is perfect
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank u so much! See you soon
Satomi S. • 1 review
December 26, 2025
10/10Every cooking was very delicious and good service.
Haoran G. • 1 review
December 27, 2025
10/10
very good
Tim M. • 14 reviews
December 26, 2025
10/10Very nice restaurant with very good food. Definitely recommend.
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank you so much! See you soon .
Maria M. • 1 review
December 25, 2025
7.5/10Great atmosphere, good food.
Sylvie B. • 6 reviews
December 3, 2025
9.5/10Very nice and friendly service. Great food .
Chuck B. • 5 reviews
November 24, 2025
10/10
+2Food was delicious! Everything we had was great. Awesome service and a cool spot to eat. Definitely recommend and would love to go back. Loved the tortelli mugellani al Peposo!!!! Florentine beef stew was great too.
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Thank u so much! See u soon
Erj T. • 5 reviews
November 1, 2025
9.5/10food was delicious... very italian... not a tourist trap. service with nice smile and sweet conversation.
Ni Z. • 1 review
September 26, 2025
10/10The food is very good. It's the best steak Ive taken.
Carolina P. • 3 reviews
October 30, 2025
10/10We liked the food so much that we had to return the next day!
Wenwen L. • 1 review
October 30, 2025
9/10
The service is excellent, and the cuisine is truly classic.
Agathe R. • 2 reviews
October 30, 2025
10/10Thank you so much for your welcome. We had an excellent moment. The food was very delicious. We recommend your restaurant for sure.
Daniel L. • 1 review
October 26, 2025
7.5/10
Pasta was excellent. Tiramisu is great. However the T bone steak is only average. I am not sure why I didn't get the forks' booking discount.
tracy S. • 5 reviews
October 23, 2025
6.5/10I was disappointed after viewing greatvreviews. I had the ragu and a salad. it lacked flavor, heavy pasta that was gluggly. I only managed half of the plate. the salad was basic and had no olives or cheese. My husband enjoyed his rooster dish.
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Gentile Sig.ra Shepherd, La ringraziamo per aver condiviso la sua esperienza. Ci dispiace sinceramente sapere che i piatti da lei ordinati non siano stati all’altezza delle aspettative, in particolare il ragù e l’insalata. Prendiamo molto sul serio le sue osservazioni e ci impegneremo a migliorare sia la qualità che la presentazione di queste portate. Siamo però lieti che suo marito abbia apprezzato il piatto di galletto, e speriamo che questo possa essere un punto di partenza per una futura visita più soddisfacente. Ci auguriamo di poterla accogliere nuovamente per offrirle un’esperienza più in linea con i nostri standard. Cordiali saluti, Lo Staff dell’Antica Trattoria Il Giardino
mo m. • 1 review
October 22, 2025
10/10good
지츄 사. • 1 review
October 12, 2025
10/10good
Philip R. • 22 reviews
October 10, 2025
5.5/10My wife had chicken, which was nice. I ordered steak in Chianti and potatoes. The steak was not as described, served on a few leaves and drizzled with red wine, rather than a rich red wine reduction sauce. The potatoes never arrived. There was then a long queue to pay the bill, as the senior person could not seem to work his computer. Overall, disappointing.
Antica Trattoria Il Giardino dal 1939 • Owner
Dear Mr Richards, we’re truly sorry for your experience. We’re sorry that the steak didn’t meet your expectations. We would be happy to welcome you back and let you taste our meat again, which is normally very appreciated for its quality and preparation. Regarding the wait at the cashier, Unfortunately, that day the restaurant was extremely busy — as it has been lately — and the may not have reflected our usual standards and additonally we had just switched to a new software system that very day to speed up orders and payments, and we apologize for any inconvenience caused. Thank you for your feedback — it helps us improve every day. Kind regards,
Tony U. • 6 reviews
October 6, 2025
7.5/10The Waitress was great! Explained the menu and provided excellent recommendations for Appetizer, Pasta and Wine. Each was terrific and we loved it! However, we ordered the Premium Florentine Steak and candidly it was not good. It was chewy, fatty and ultimately we ate maybe had. The Florentine Steak for two was 120 Euros, not worth any amount. Take the steak out and we give our experience a 9.5.
ashok c. • 1 review
October 5, 2025
7/10Steak is really tough. Great flavor but not great quality meat.
Ann S. • 23 reviews
September 30, 2025
10/10Small charming restaurant, attentive staff. Although we ate lightly, the beef steak salad (excellent by the way) and dessert, and no wine we were treated warmly, not hurried. We plan to return.
георгий и. • 10 reviews
September 29, 2025
10/10
Food
Arba Z. • 1 review
September 28, 2025
10/10Exellent
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.