Reviews - Il Paiolo
Reviews
9.1of 10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
Beau C. • 1 review
April 21, 2025
10/10The steak, staff, and atmosphere was incredible!! Arber was an amazing host and we look forward to visiting again!
Jessica C. • 1 review
April 16, 2025
10/10
Really good food, service and location. You hear stories about how it’s tourist-priced, but to be honest, even if you walk further out, the prices are similar—maybe €4/5 cheaper. For the portion size and quality of the food, it was bellisimo. The fillet I ordered was melt-in-your-mouth delicious, followed by the potatoes and the garlic butter spinach. The Bolognese was tomato-rich and delicious, and the wild boar was full of flavours.
Sofia P. • 4 reviews
March 26, 2025
10/10Very nice place and great service. It is a must try
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very muchSofia for your wonderful review! We are happy that you enjoyed our authentic Tuscan cuisine and the warm and romantic atmosphere of our restaurant. We look forward to seeing you soon to let you taste new traditional dishes! See you soon
Andrea N. • 2 reviews
March 23, 2025
10/10
Don’t miss this beautiful restaurant in the heart of history.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Andrea for the nice review on our Il Paiolo Romantic Restaurant. We are happy that you enjoyed the excellent food as well as the kindness and efficiency of the staff. We look forward to seeing you next time! A warm greeting from all the staff
Nadia P. • 1 review
March 12, 2025
10/10Michele and the staff were excellent. We got the bruschetta and octopus to start and they were both the best we’ve had in Italy. We shared a steak and gnocchi for our main and born weee delicious. Great place to eat while in Florence for sure!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you Nadia for the nice review We are glad you enjoyed our menu full of Tuscan specialties! Each dish is prepared as the ingredients selected to ensure the true taste of traditional cuisine We are waiting for you for another gastronomic experience at Il Paiolo!
Gary A. • 1 review
March 12, 2025
10/10The food the service and the atmosphere
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you Gary for your nice review! We are happy that you enjoyed our authentic Tuscan cuisine and the warm and romantic atmosphere of our restaurant. We look forward to seeing you soon to let you taste new traditional dishes! See you soon
Mafalda F. • 2 reviews
March 5, 2025
10/10
A beautiful place. we sat at a table by the window and it was very romantic. the staff were all very attentive and the food was very good.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you Mafalda for choosing Il Paiolo for your special evening! Creating an intimate and welcoming atmosphere is one of our priorities, along with the quality of our typical Tuscan dishes. We look forward to seeing you soon for another unforgettable experience!
jiaxi l. • 3 reviews
January 15, 2025
9/10
The environment inside restaurant is very good.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Dear Jiaxi, Thank you very much for the nice review on our Il Paiolo Romantic Restaurant. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. We look forward to seeing you next time! A warm greeting from all the staff
Rainbow W. • 3 reviews
December 27, 2024
10/10The food was nice
Il Paiolo • Owner
Dear Rainbow , Thank you very much for the nice review on our Il Paiolo Romantic Restaurant. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. We look forward to seeing you next time! A warm greeting from all the staff
Marcia F. • 6 reviews
October 24, 2024
10/10
The food was tasty and well presented. The tiramisu was the best I have ever tasted. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Marcia for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Francesco L. • 2 reviews
October 2, 2024
10/10
Top...
Il Paiolo • Owner
Grazie ancora Francesco per questa recensione positiva e per il tempo che vi hai dedicato! È stato davvero un grande piacere potervi accogliere di nuovo nel nostro ristorante e lo è ancora di più sapere di essere riusciti a soddisfare i nostri clienti. Le nostre porte sono sempre aperte, Ci auguriamo di rivedervi presto!
Daniel M. • 1 review
September 29, 2024
9.5/10
Very good food and nice ambiance. Restaurant was busy and we had a wait even with our reservation.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Daniel for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Molly D. • 1 review
September 23, 2024
9/10Food was great! Would recommend!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Molly for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Min Su k. • 1 review
September 21, 2024
7.5/10server is not kind ignore the sign
Il Paiolo • Owner
Gentile Min Su Kim Sono molto dispiaciuto per la sua cattiva esperienza nel nostro Ristorante. Non ne andiamo certo orgogliosi e come può vedere dalle altre recensioni si tratta di un episodio alquanto insolito. Spero che vorrà tornare da noi così possiamo riparare in qualche modo alla sua delusione
Judy H. • 1 review
September 15, 2024
5.5/10We were so looking forward to our meal, after all the hype about this restaurant! Arrived, and it took a while to get our order in, and get a glass of wine. Ok, so anticipation still high, my fillet arrived, and was so sinewy, I had trouble cutting through it!! I complained, and a second one was made, only to be exactly the same! My friend, who had ordered the steak with greens and Parmesan, was given hers, a pale gray color, which not only looked anemic, but certainly didn’t live up to their reputation! The roast potatoes were anemic too!! !the staff was friendly enough, but it didn’t make up for the experience!!
Gary P. • 2 reviews
September 4, 2024
10/10Excellent ravioli and sautéed spinach.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you v Iery much Gary for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Frankie C. • 1 review
September 2, 2024
10/10
Best steak I’ve ever had!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you v Iery much Frankiefor sharing with us your experience at Ristorante il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
ANAHID Y. • 1 review
August 22, 2024
6.5/10We had reservations but we had to wait 30 minutes to be sitted . Inside the restaurant was very nice, romantic, they had a great wine selection .We ordered tomato bruschetta, salad, steak and grilled vegetables . Everything was great except the most important dish. Our steaks looked beautiful but impossible to eat , it was 90% fat , barely any meat on it, difficult to chew. After couple of bites I gave up , I only ate my salad and the vegetables, they were good, I guess you can’t go wrong with that ( salad comes without any dressing, you have to mix it on your on with evoo and balsamic vinegar)and when the waiter asked how was my food I told him exactly how I felt about it, to my surprise he didn’t even offer something else or a refund. He simply said that’s how it is. I’m not a complainer neither is my husband, but we both were very disappointed:( For a restaurant like that I would expect a better service, unfortunately I will never go back.
Agnès R. • 14 reviews
July 20, 2024
9.5/10The food was really good 😊 but you’ve had to ask for your reduction ;) Great place for an excellent dinner!!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Agnes for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Monica Laura b. • 31 reviews
July 17, 2024
9/10very good food and wine
Jessica L. • 1 review
July 17, 2024
10/10This restaurant was the perfect ending to our stay in Florence. The ambiance of the restaurant is charming and intimate. We tried pasta and steak and everything was delicious. The service was also excellent! Highly recommend!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Jessica for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Liz B. • 1 review
June 24, 2024
10/10
We visited Rome, Florence, and Positano on our trip, and this was - hands down - the best meal we had in Italy! I had the steak with brandy, walnut, and Gorgonzola sauce and my daughter had the pasta cooked in a pecorino cheese wheel. Both were DELICIOUS!! The waiter who made the pasta was fantastic! So fun and entertaining! Again, we had a lot of great food in Italy but this was our favorite dinner!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Liz for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Sabatini / Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
michael c. • 5 reviews
June 24, 2024
3/10It gives me no pleasure in saying that this was a poor experience. It was very clear the restaurant was very popular and so understandably busy - however when presented with a table next to an open kitchen door we should have walked out. I'm sorry, the three tables in this back kitchen corner are no way near representative of the images presented when making a booking. The service was inconsistent and poor, twice we had to flag down over stretched staff having been abandoned. Having multiple waiters didn’t engender a pleasant customer experience. Food - alas should have been exceptional but didn’t live up to expectations. Steak, acceptable a little fatty but nothing wonderful. This being said having had several similar steaks in recent days. All in all, a disappointing and costly evening.
Shannon D. • 5 reviews
June 23, 2024
6/10We were excited to try this restaurant but left dissatisfied. The carbonara dish we ordered was delicious but our ribeyes were not the greatest. Our waiter seemed uninterested in assisting our table after we did not want to order the 175 dollar wine he suggested since we decided to stay in the ~ 50 dollar range. He didn’t check on our table throughout our meal…We had to get his assistant server to gain his attention. She was great and assist us with what we needed! The manager tried to offer us dessert to make the situation better but still charged for the ribeye even though it was not eaten after he said he was going to remove it from the bill.
Megan G. • 2 reviews
June 20, 2024
10/10
Amazing restaurant! By far our best food in Rome! I had the bolognese and others had lasagna and filet steak! Everything was great the service was the best we had in Florence also! Very attentive! We had Romy as our server and she was so nice and helpful! Would definitely go back!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Megan for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Sequoyah P. • 1 review
June 11, 2024
10/10Great host and great food!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Sequoyah for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Romain D. • 62 reviews
June 3, 2024
10/10Excellent food
Carlos R. • 1 review
June 2, 2024
10/10The dinner was wonderful!! Me and my wife, we love it!! Special thanks for Nina!! And, you must taste the Bisteca Fiorentina!! 10/10!!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Carlos for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Jill G. • 2 reviews
May 20, 2024
10/10We had the steak and potatoes plus the minestrone soup. Everything was delicious. We noticed the steaks were really rare so we ordered medium and it was perfect. The little light on the ceiling made the place really pretty at night. I would highly recommend. Make sure you have a reservation.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Jill for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Yeonseo O. • 1 review
May 14, 2024
10/10
Reasonable price, good service, perfect foods!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much yeonseofor sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Sabati il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Samuel M. • 1 review
May 4, 2024
10/10We had an amazing dinner here! The food was lovely, the service was exceptional and the restaurant itself had a lovely atmosphere. We recommend the bistecca florentina - simply amazing!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Samuel for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Sylvia M. • 1 review
April 22, 2024
8/10Great restaurant with nice ambiance, little pricey. Pasta tagliolini was delicious
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Sylvia for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Yuksel T. • 5 reviews
April 9, 2024
10/10Really good service specially Romina was really perfect as the kitchen. Overall experience was very good. The quality of the food olive oil and balsamic was perfect taste wonderful. Traditional domates soup and risotto you should taste.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Yuksel for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Natalia K. • 62 reviews
April 7, 2024
9.5/10Very good food. Nice service!
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Natalia for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Adrian A. • 1 review
February 14, 2024
9/10
The steak wasn't the best, we had to chew it for a very long time However, pastas were very good
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Adrian for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Yermekbayeva D. • 6 reviews
January 4, 2024
9/10The food and the ambiance was fantastic but we were disappointed that the restaurant did not offer the 20% discount that was advertised on The Fork app. Having booked the table with this offer, we expected it to to be automatically included to the bill but later got an email from the Fork saying that we did not attend the booking. So the restaurant did not report us coming and hence did not provide the 20 percent dicount offer
Ilaria L. • 2 reviews
December 9, 2023
10/10Good food, nice environment for lunch with friends or family.
Il Paiolo • Owner
Thank you very much Ilaria Losito for sharing with us your experience at Ristorante Il Paiolo. It makes us very happy to read that everything was to your liking and that thanks to the preparation of our staff you were able to enjoy a romantic experience among the flavours of Tuscan tradition in a unique location in the heart of Florence. It was a great pleasure to welcome you to our restaurant. Our doors are always open, we hope to see you soon!
Khaled E. • 27 reviews
October 31, 2023
7/10We wanted to taste a nice bistecca alla fiorentina, we went for their best aged piece but it was really disappointing, the meat was as tender as they said, we had much better for much less.
Rebecca E. • 2 reviews
October 1, 2023
6/10Tourist restaurant—all we heard was English being spoken throughout the restaurant—I would not recommend this restaurant for foodies or for those seeking a local experience. Steak was over cooked pursuant to what we requested which was medium rare, vegetable appetizer was luke warm, bread was not heated and borderline stale. Artichoke risotto was good. Check was presented before requested which we have never experienced in Europe ever. Then we were told where we could go pay which was right next to the bar and close to other diners which made it impossible to split the bill without disturbing other diners. So one of us paid the entire bill so we could leave quickly.
Ken W. • 1 review
September 18, 2023
2/10Terrible
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.