For restaurants
Help


Reviews - La Tavernetta da Piero

Reviews

8.8/10

Fabulous
416 reviews
Ambience
8.4
Food
9.1
Service
8.7
Real experiences from real diners
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.

All reviews

  • Tom M.6 months ago

    8.5

    Excellent typical Siciliano food. Great flavors, well prepared pasta and fish. Great value for the money. Just what we were hoping for.

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Grazie mille

  • eric z.11 months ago

    9.5

    My 2nd visit to the family-run restaurant since last one in January - a foodie from Toronto Canada . Food is amazing. Grilled sea bream, grilled octopus, risotto…I can’t say they’re the best, but I can say it’s hard to find something better when you pay 50% more at a star-granted eatery.

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Grazie mille

  • Philip I.1 year ago

    8.5

    We enjoyed our visit to this restaurant. It was our second visit and we will be happy to return. They hadn’t received our booking via the Fork app but we could be accommodated anyway. Fish is the mainstay and is well done

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Thanks

  • Jeanne R.1 year ago

    9.5

    This is such a gem! A lively neighborhood restaurant where people are enjoying great food and having a good time. We loved the food so much that we came back a second time (with 3 days in Siracusa). Everyone is using the delicious bread to sop up the last bits of the outstanding sauces. The seafood is so very fresh and expertly prepared. The staff is family and they spread their joy to their guests.

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Thanks

  • Yasushi K.1 year ago

    7.5

    Excellent food with very friendly services at casual atmosphere

  • JUDY F.1 year ago

    10

    Recommended by our Air Bnb hosts this place was a great find. Excellent food, lovely staff, nice atmosphere. Very popular so reservations recommended. We loved everything- pasta, seafood, pistachio parfait and wine. great value too.

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Thanks for the review

  • Daniel S.1 year ago

    9.5

    Really great food here, not touristy, great value.

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Thanks

  • Viorel M.1 year ago

    10

    Superb

    La Tavernetta da Piero

    Grazie mille

  • Sara N.
    Sara N.more than 2 years

    10

    We had an amazing experience and a lovely dinner at La Tavernetta da Piero. The place was nice, the waiter that attended us was sympatic and aware of the details and of our needs. The products were fresh, well prepared and the flavours were all there. The portions were generous, we were two and shared a plate of pasta and a plate of fish. As we said on the beggining that the plates were to share, they served the portion divided in one plate for each and it was a great quantity of food. The quality-price relation is good for the served food (ok, it's a bit expensive but it is justified for all the service presented). I recommend this place when visiting Ortigia!

  • Monique Z.more than 2 years

    9.0

    Amazing food to tease your taste buds with awesome reasonable prices

  • - -.more than 2 years

    5.5

    The antipasti and pasta dishes were ordered were not well prepared, balanced in taste or good quality. A disappointing experience. I would recommend choose another restaurant

  • - -.more than 2 years

    9.5

    Very good food and service. I had the sea bass with lemon sauce and it was delicious. The cypress salad was good but the tomatoes were not very ripe or sweet. The mozzarella, however, was very good. It was a very enjoyable meal. Reservations are necessary.

  • - -.more than 2 years

    9.5

    we really enjoyed this restaurant. It is obviously used by both local people and visitors. We thought the food and wine selection were very good.

  • - -.more than 2 years

    9.5

    Very enjoyable evening and certainly lived up to expectations. But don’t each too much beforehand!

  • Rob O.more than 2 years

    9.5

    After the confusion with which of the 2 restaurants we were booked into so it might be an idea when you book with the fork someone from the restaurant should indicate which one instead of getting loads of shrugs from the waiters and a lot of Italian hand gestures from a person sitting at a table by the bar who I presume was the owner. It was very busy in our restaurant when we were seated so no time for “Would you like water for the table naturalie or fritzanti” However we cheered the waiters up and made them smile and we had a laugh. Food was excellent fish was the freshest we had had in Ortigia so far. And the price was reasonable too

Tripadvisor reviews

Tripadvisor
3108 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

Book a table

For free

Are you a restaurant owner?

Register your Restaurant

Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible

Already a Client

Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.

Download our App

  • Download from the App Store
  • Get it on Google Play
  • About
  • Loyalty program
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Are you a restaurant?
  • Privacy and Cookies Statement
  • Frequently asked questions
  • We are hiring
  • MICHELIN Guide Partnership
  • Restaurant near me

© 2026 La FourchetteSAS - All rights reserved

Promotional offers are subject to conditions displayed on the restaurant’s page. Offers on alcoholic beverages are strictly reserved for adults. Alcohol abuse is dangerous for your health. Drink with moderation.