Reviews - Le Sergent Recruteur
Reviews
9.4/10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
All reviews
10
Thoughtful cuisine in a beautiful space on delightful Ile St. Louis. Great service and wine pairings. Very reasonably priced. This was my sixth visit. Le SR never disappoints. Go! You’ll love it!!!
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Anne, Thank you very much for your wonderful feedback and for your loyalty. We are truly delighted to know that your sixth visit to Le Sergent Recruteur was once again such an enjoyable experience. Your kind words about the cuisine, the service, the wine pairings and the atmosphere on Île Saint-Louis mean a great deal to our entire team. We look forward to welcoming you back for many more visits in the future. Kind regards, Margot — Customer Manager
6.0
My dessert was delicious but the entree with relatively thick slices of dry mushrooms on top of a pile of pearl couscous and some scallop foam (I think) on the side was a monochromatic pile of practically tasteless items. Definitely not worthy of a 1 star restaurant. My main course of fish was fresh but not memorable. I would really rethink those items. Also, presentation was not great. The items and plating had little to no decor, thus contributing even more to the “has anyone really examined this” feeling. Service and ambiance were good. Redoing some of the menu is recommended.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Jennifer, Thank you for taking the time to share such a detailed and thoughtful review. We are sorry to read that part of your dining experience did not meet your expectations, particularly regarding the starter and the fish course. Your comments about flavors, balance and presentation have been carefully noted and shared with our team. Feedback as precise as yours is important to us, as it helps us continuously reflect on and refine our menu. We are however pleased to read that you appreciated the dessert, as well as the service and the ambiance of the restaurant. We thank you again for your visit and for sharing your perspective. Kind regards, Margot — Customer Manager
10
This is a second time we came here. Everything is perfect: exquisite food, superb service, great atmosphere, reasonable prices for such a unique place. This is our must go restaurant in Paris.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Susan, Thank you very much for your wonderful feedback and for your loyalty. We are delighted to read that your second visit was once again perfect, from the exquisite food to the service, atmosphere and value for such a unique place. Knowing that Le Sergent Recruteur has become your must-go restaurant in Paris truly means a lot to our entire team. We look forward to welcoming you again very soon. Kind regards, Margot — Customer Manager
10
Good food
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Siu Lun, Thank you very much for your kind feedback. We are delighted that you enjoyed the food and hope to welcome you again soon at Le Sergent Recruteur. Kind regards, Margot — Customer Manager
6.0
I was looking for an outstanding meal and was very disappointed. We chose the multi course lunch. The appetizer was never served, the amuse bouche was a soup like mixture with noodles and a slice of veal on top that was supposed to be warm not hot but was actually cool at its center. The chef apologized. The raw scallops with sliced carrots were tasteless. Oysters were substituted for mussels in the another course. The mango pallet cleanser was thankfully substituted for the
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Ellen, Thank you for taking the time to share your detailed feedback following your lunch with us. We are truly sorry to read that your experience did not meet your expectations, particularly as you were looking forward to an outstanding meal. We regret the inconsistencies you encountered during the service, including the missing course and the temperature and balance of certain dishes. While our chef did address some of these points during your visit, we fully understand that this does not make up for the overall disappointment you felt. Your comments regarding flavors, substitutions, and pacing have been carefully noted and shared with both the kitchen and dining room teams, as they help us reflect on where we must improve to ensure a consistently high-level experience for our guests. Thank you again for your honesty. We hope that, should you give us another opportunity in the future, we may offer you an experience more in line with the standards we strive to uphold. Margot – Customer Manager
10
Good selection of varied options on the menu. Also accommodated gluten free for the majority of the dishes. Service was great with strong attention to detail. We had reservations, don't know if that was required or not but the restaurant was full on a Wednesday night. Definitely recommend.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Gwen, Thank you very much for your kind review. We’re delighted that you appreciated both the variety of our menu and the attention of our team, as well as our efforts to accommodate your gluten-free options. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we would be delighted to welcome you again on your next visit to Paris. Margot – Customer Manager
10
Lunch. Lovely looking place, friendly greeting. Amuse bouche delicious spread with toasts. 3 courses, first a tomato with smoked eel, figs, cheese wonderful, then salmon , julienne veggies, beef, broth,emulsion, tempura, delightful texture s and flavors. Pear dessert exquisite! Followed by succulent mignonette! Attentive service.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Nancy, We are delighted to read your kind words and to know that each course, from the amuse-bouche to dessert, left you with such a positive impression. Your appreciation of both the cuisine and the attentive service means a lot to us. We would be very happy to welcome you again on a future visit to Paris. Margot – Customer Manager
10
From entering to leaving, the service was first class. All backed up by exceptional food and wine.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Andrew, Thank you very much for your kind words. We’re delighted that both the service and the combination of food and wine made your experience so enjoyable from start to finish. We look forward to welcoming you again on a future visit to Paris. Margot – Customer Manager
10
Service was impeccable, from the moment we entered the space until we were done, flawless execution really Bravo!
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Val-Jerry, Thank you so much for your kind words. We're truly delighted that you felt so well taken care of from start to finish — your praise for the service and execution means a great deal to our entire team. We look forward to welcoming you back for another flawless experience. Margot – Customer Manager
10
A great location on a quiet street on Ile St. Louis. Service and the food are elegant and outstanding. The experience was lots of fun and are looking forward to returning to Le Sargent Recruteur on our next trip to Paris!
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Thomas, Thank you for your kind words. We're delighted that you enjoyed the calm setting, as well as the elegance of both our cuisine and service. It’s a pleasure to know your experience was fun and memorable — we’ll be very happy to welcome you back on your next visit to Paris! Margot – Customer Manager
9.0
Our "last night" dinner, staying on Ile St. Louis. The maitre'd was kind and welcoming and sat us with a great view of the kitchen (if you love watching chefs). We had the 5 course tasting menu with added wine pairing - something we always appreciate. First, a plump muscle sitting atop a bowl of mouse with teeny frites. The muscle was great, but I couldn't eat the mouse as it was just the beginning! An amuse bouche should be only a "bite" of delicious. Then came smoked mackerel with finger toasts. I could have eaten it all. It was wonderful, but again, too much. Swordfish ceviche w caviar was a dream - and beautifully plated with tiny petals on citrus sauce. The girolles were also excellent, and grilled almonds a lovely addition. Poultry with black garlic, perfectly executed and the cherry desert, just heaven. Service was uneven though, attentive at first, and as it got busier, we were left waiting. Not even offered coffee. I would skip the wine pairing. Worth a visit. They'll grow.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear David, Thank you for taking the time to share such detailed and thoughtful feedback. We’re delighted that your final dinner in Paris was a memorable one, and that you enjoyed the creativity of the tasting menu — from the swordfish ceviche to the cherry dessert. Your remarks regarding portion balance, pacing of service, and the wine pairing are much appreciated and have been shared with our team. We’re always striving to refine every aspect of the experience. It would be a pleasure to welcome you again and show you how we’ve grown. Margot – Customer Manager
10
+3Amazing place with a memorable starter.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Adrian, Thank you for your kind words! We’re delighted that you enjoyed your experience with us — and especially that the starter left a lasting impression. We look forward to welcoming you again soon. Margot – Customer Manager
10
Service was excellent, we had 5 course tasting menu and my wife and I thoroughly enjoyed each course. Beautiful plating, sauces were exceptional, and the wine pairings were spot on.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear John, Thank you for your wonderful feedback. We’re delighted that you and your wife enjoyed each course of the tasting menu, and that the wine pairings and sauces stood out. Your kind words about the service and presentation mean a great deal to us. We look forward to welcoming you again for another memorable experience. Margot – Customer Manager
9.5
Food is absolutely incredible. It was the best fois gras I’ve ever had. Even the classic dishes have a creative twist. I happened to be there on an extremely busy night, and the restaurant is fully packed. The staff were trying their best to serve everyone but was a bit understaffed
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Qiaozu, Thank you for your thoughtful and generous feedback. We're truly delighted that you found the cuisine exceptional and appreciated the creativity in our dishes — especially the foie gras! We also take note of your comment regarding the service on a particularly busy evening. Your understanding means a lot, and we continuously strive to maintain high standards, even during peak times. We hope to welcome you again soon for an even smoother experience. Margot – Customer Manager
10
Everything was fantastic, cuisine, atmosphere, personnel. All it made our visit special and memorable.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Oleg, Thank you very much for your wonderful feedback. We are delighted that the cuisine, atmosphere, and service contributed to making your visit special and memorable. We look forward to welcoming you again soon. Margot – Customer Manager
7.0
I had high hopes based on past reviews but my experience was only ok. The service and ambiance were as expected but the food was nothing special, especially for the price, which is on the high side.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Jennifer, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. While we are pleased that you appreciated the service and ambiance, we’re sorry to read that the cuisine did not fully meet your expectations. Taste is, of course, highly subjective, but we hope that should you decide to visit us again, the experience will be more aligned with what you had hoped for. Margot – Customer Manager
9.5
Excellent dining and great ambience. Wait staff was terrific.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Norma, Thank you very much for your kind words. We are delighted that you enjoyed both the ambiance and the service during your visit. We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you again soon for another memorable experience. Margot – Customer Manager
2.0
The food is really bad. No tasted
Le Sergent RecruteurWe must admit that your review stands in stark contrast to the overwhelming majority of feedback we receive — which consistently highlights the precision of our flavors and the high quality of our cuisine. That said, your review omits important context. From the moment you arrived, both you and "your guest" displayed disrespectful behavior toward our team — mocking our servers and speaking to them inappropriately. You demanded “the best table” based on an email you allegedly sent, which we never received — did you truly send it? It’s difficult not to read your review as a form of retaliation for not being given what you considered a “prestigious” seat. If your visit was merely a performance to impress your "companion", perhaps it would be wise to refine your palate before reviewing restaurants of this standard. We take pride in our work, and while we accept constructive criticism, your comment — lacking any nuance or substance — says more about your intentions than about your experience. Sincerely, Margot
10
An enjoyable evening - a lovely ambience, an excellent meal, exquisitely prepared and presented and friendly service. Would certainly return when in Paris and recommend to others, particularlyfor a special occasion too.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Elizabeth, Thank you very much for your kind words. We’re delighted to know you enjoyed your evening with us — from the atmosphere to the quality and presentation of the dishes, as well as the service. It would be a pleasure to welcome you again whenever you’re in Paris. Thank you also for recommending us for special occasions — that means a lot to the whole team. Margot – Customer Manager
10
We have visited here twice within one year. The food is excellent, service is great and right to the appropriate level. Every dish will give you excitement for the tasting and we will definitely come back again.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Leo, Thank you for your continued trust and for sharing such wonderful feedback. We are delighted to hear that each of your visits has been marked by exceptional food and attentive service. Knowing that every dish brought excitement to your tasting experience truly warms our hearts. We look forward to welcoming you back for another memorable meal at Le Sergent Recruteur. Warm regards, Margot - Customer Manager
10
Amazing food and ambiance. Perfect start to vacay in France
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Peter, Thank you for choosing Le Sergent Recruteur to start your vacation in France. We’re thrilled to hear that both the food and ambiance contributed to a perfect beginning to your trip. We hope the rest of your stay is just as delightful and that we’ll have the pleasure of welcoming you back soon. Warm regards, Margot - Customer Manager
10
Excellent dishes, great services and good wine offered. Will be back when we are in Paris
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Thok Chuan Tran, Thank you so much for your kind words. We’re delighted to hear that you enjoyed the dishes, service, and wine selection during your visit. It would be a pleasure to welcome you back whenever you’re in Paris again. Looking forward to your next visit, Margot - Customer Manager
9.0
The main course was not that great, but the rest superb!
Le Sergent RecruteurThank you very much, Gerhard. We’re delighted to read that you thoroughly enjoyed most of your meal, and we take note of your comment about the main course. We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you back soon for an even more flawless experience. Margot – Customer Manager
10
What a beautiful experience and something special to remember our time in Paris. The service was impeccable and the food was absolutely wonderful. Would definitely highly recommend a visit.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Janet, Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear that your experience with us was memorable and that both the service and the food exceeded your expectations. It means a lot to us that you would highly recommend our restaurant. We hope to welcome you back the next time you're in Paris! Margot – Customer Manager
10
Good
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Minjie, Thank you for your kind feedback! We are happy to know that you had a good experience with us. Best regards, Margot - Responsable de Clientèle
10
This gem, located on Ile St Louis, is a sensational dining experience! We are so lucky to have stumbled across it after our Notre Dame visit (the mostly pedestrian cobblestone island is located just behind it). The meticulous attention to detail of every course is experienced with every bite. The big highlights were the melt in your mouth Turbot (white fish) and Cerf frotté (steak). The desserts are a work of art - true mouthwatering masterpieces of creativity. I hesitate to share this review because it feels like a beautifully designed neighborhood secret. Everyone spoke French around us, and it felt like we discovered a hidden treasure.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Kelly, Thank you so much for your glowing review! We're thrilled that you had such an exceptional experience at Le Sergent Recruteur and that our attention to detail and the flavors of our dishes left a lasting impression. We are honored to be considered a hidden gem, and we can't wait to welcome you back for another memorable meal. Warm regards, Margot - Customer Manager
10
We enjoyed a wonderful evening on Ile St Louis. The dinner was outstanding, a delightful experience filled with sophisticated flavors and elegant attention to detail.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Indy, Thank you for your wonderful review! We're delighted to hear that you had an outstanding evening with us on Île Saint-Louis. It’s a pleasure to know that you enjoyed the sophisticated flavors and the attention to detail in our dishes. We look forward to welcoming you back soon for another delightful experience. Best regards, Margot - Customer Manager
8.0
The appetiser was really nice , main was ok not as wow as the appetiser!
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Angel, Thank you for sharing your experience. We're delighted that you enjoyed the appetizer and that it left a strong impression! We take note of your feedback on the main course and always strive to refine our dishes to create a consistently exceptional experience. We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you again soon. Best regards, Margot - Customer Manager
10
Excellent !!!
Le Sergent RecruteurChère Nina, Merci pour votre retour si positif ! Nous sommes ravis que votre expérience ait été à la hauteur de vos attentes. À très bientôt pour un nouveau moment de gourmandise ! Margot - Responsable Clientèle
2.5
Definitely not worth the money
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Javier, Thank you for sharing your feedback. We are sorry to hear that your experience did not meet your expectations. We always strive to provide excellent value to our guests and would appreciate the opportunity to better understand what may have fallen short during your visit. Please do not hesitate to contact us directly. Margot – Customer Manager
6.0
This is the second time at Le Sergent Recruteur (prior dinner in 2014). We went for lunch on 12/7/24 and Chef Alain Pegouret created lovely haute dishes. The food was divine. However the experienced stopped there ... having 2 servers sweating like bullets, barely holding it together and plopping our food down (no after dinner coffee or drinks or anything but the check?) ... was subpar. I am sorry they were short-staffed that day, I am sorry the Notre-Dame opening caused chaos around the city that weekend, I am sorry we had high expectations as were repeat customers, but the atmosphere in 2014 was lovely, delicious and fun with a depth of flavors and this was a borderline shit-show getting the food from the kitchen to the table. Chef Pegouret needs to review his whole package .... our experience at FIEF was fun as was Kei (a whole other level), but we are going to pass on encouraging our friends from visiting Le Sergent Recruteur and it will not be on our next stop in Paris.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Ann, Thank you for sharing your detailed feedback with us. We are delighted to hear that you appreciated Chef Alain Pégouret's cuisine and found the dishes divine. However, we are sincerely sorry to learn that the overall experience did not meet your expectations. The high level of service is one of our priorities, and we regret that the atmosphere and attentiveness were not what they should have been during your visit. While external circumstances like the reopening of Notre-Dame may have impacted the city that day, it is our responsibility to ensure that our guests feel welcomed and cared for at all times. We truly value your loyalty and the fact that you chose to return after several years. Your observations are taken very seriously and will be shared with the team to ensure continuous improvement. We hope that you might reconsider visiting us in the future and allow us the opportunity to provide you with the exceptional experience you once enjoyed. Margot – Customer Manager
8.5
+5the foie gras is the best thing i have ever eaten and a chef's specialty. all of the savory food was amazing, from fish to meat. the sauce chef is a master and all of his preparations are masterpieces. sweet food on the other hand was not to my liking. it looked complex and was well executed but was not as enjoyable as the starters or the entrees. i would come back but get dessert some place else.
Le Sergent RecruteurThank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We are delighted that you enjoyed the foie gras, our savory dishes, and the sauces crafted by our talented team. Your kind words about their mastery mean a lot to us. We regret that the desserts did not meet your expectations and appreciate your honesty. Your observations help us refine our offerings and ensure every aspect of the experience is memorable. We hope to welcome you back soon for another culinary journey! Best regards, Margot - Customer Manager
9.5
Solo and couple diners - beware the green alcove. The food was impeccable, delicious, and creative. Service was absolutely amazing. I couldn’t have asked for more in those departments. However, as previous reviews I have read warned, there is a table/seat that is horrendous and I had the displeasure of experiencing it (I took a chance). The green alcove seat (the only one in the house) is deeply recessed, forcing you to sit on the edge of your seat with barely enough room for your arms to move about freely when eating. It also faces another (extremely close) table and the back of the house. The only redeeming aspect is you can witness the chefs working their magic (if that’s what you may be interested in). Unsure if I will return.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Sean, Thank you for sharing your detailed feedback. We are thrilled that you found our food impeccable and our service amazing—this means a great deal to us. Regarding your experience with the seating, we sincerely appreciate your observations. While we aim to create a comfortable and enjoyable setting for all our guests, we take note of your comments about the green alcove seat and will reflect on ways to improve. Should you decide to return, we’d be happy to accommodate a seating request to ensure your comfort. We hope to have the chance to welcome you again for another memorable dining experience. Margot - Customer Manager
10
Excellent and unique experience Highly recommended
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Itai, Thank you for your kind words and recommendation! We’re delighted that you had an excellent and unique experience at Le Sergent Recruteur. Providing memorable moments for our guests is what we strive for, and your feedback motivates us to keep delivering our best. We hope to welcome you back soon for another exceptional culinary journey. Warm regards, Margot - Customer Manager
5.0
The stars were not aligned for our experience at Le Sergent Recruteur. We take pleasure in reviewing the wine list and selecting a bottle to pair with our meal. We had a few suggestions in mind and asked the sommelier for feedback. The response was rushed and resulted in the suggestion of a good wine with a 450% mark up. The bottle arrived on our table a few minutes later, opened with no cork to inspect. Never presented to us. One of our meals was the special, a slow cooked white rabbit with risotto. The first bite was dense and salty. The taste improved when the risotto, presented in a side dish, was mixed into the dense rabbit sauce. Hopefully, the stars will align for future diners at Le Sergent Recruteur, but for now our forecast is cloudy with a chance of rain.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Steve, Thank you for sharing your thoughts about your experience at Le Sergent Recruteur. We regret to hear that certain aspects, such as the wine selection process and presentation, fell short of expectations. Your comments have been shared with our sommelier team to ensure improvements are made. While we're glad the rabbit and risotto flavors came together for you, we acknowledge your initial impression and will take your feedback into account to refine our dishes further. Thank you again for helping us improve. We hope to welcome you back for an experience that meets your expectations. Warm regards, Margot - Customer Manager
5.0
+4The service is not well. Some dishes are good and some aren”t. Not worth a star for a fine dining experience
Le Sergent RecruteurThank you for sharing your feedback with us. We take all comments seriously, as every palate is different, and we appreciate your perspective. We strive for excellence in both our service and our dishes, and we are sorry to hear that your experience did not meet your expectations. We would welcome the opportunity to discuss your experience further, as we are committed to continuously improving. Please feel free to reach out to us directly. We hope to have the chance to provide you with the fine dining experience we aspire to deliver. Best regards, Margot - Customer Manager
10
Excellence service and Food!!! We can say they really know what they're doing to provide great dinner experience with best ingredients.
Le Sergent RecruteurThank you so much for your wonderful review! We are thrilled that you enjoyed both our service and our cuisine. At Le Sergent Recruteur, our team is dedicated to crafting unique dining experiences using only the finest ingredients. Your satisfaction is our greatest reward. We look forward to welcoming you again soon ! Margot - Customer Manager
10
Good food, Good people
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Yongoh, thank you very much for your comment that we read with pleasure ! We will share it with our entire team and our Chef Alain Pegouret and we hope to welcome you again soon. Sincerely, Margot - Customer Manager
10
Nice service and food
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Yuling, Thank you very much for your comment we will share it with our entire team and we hope to welcome you again soon ! Margot - Customer Manager
10
The service and food were fantastic. It’s innovative, beautiful tasting food.
Le Sergent RecruteurDear Charles, Thank you very much for your comment, it's a real pleasure to read that your enjoyed your full experience in our establishment from the food to the service. Of course we will share it with our entire team and our chef Alain Pegouret. We hope to welcome you again soon, Margot - Customer Manager
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.