For restaurants
Help


Reviews - Osteria "Baccano" Restaurant

Reviews

9/10

Excellent
1804 reviews
Ambience
8.9
Food
9.0
Service
9.2
Real experiences from real diners
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.

All reviews

  • anthony f.3 months ago

    10

    Good food great service

  • Alexandra B.6 months ago

    10

    A great find slightly away from the crowds. Excellent list of specials on the day we visited, all delicious. Very friendly service.

  • Raphaelle B.10 months ago

    10

    You should definitely get the pig!

  • Chad O.
    Chad O.1 year ago

    10

    We had a great dinner here! The food was delicious and the service was great!

  • Elisabetta C.1 year ago

    10

    excellent food and served with a smile

  • Stefano E.1 year ago

    9.0

    Very good food, nice ambiance, good service. Very nice location

  • Chris S.1 year ago

    10

    Really friendly and helpful staff made us feel most welcome. Lovely ambience under brick built arches and exciting art on the walls. Delicious herb and spiced beef, lovely roast potatoes and a mixed salad with a marvellously fresh green olive oil. An excellent Brunello recommended by the waiter.

  • Stephen M.1 year ago

    7.5

    Lovely food. Very bright lighting and generic music so not much ambience. Good food in a cafe setting

  • Sandra A.2 years ago

    7.5

    Arrived early for our booking & shown to our table . We were the only guests so it was lovely & quiet inside . Bread & water arrived the we ordered & asked if we could omit mushrooms which was no problem . Requested a small portion as hate food waste. Food was delicious & still a huge portion of pasta . Hubby had pizza which was a bit over fired as crust was tough to cut but again delicious . Great value & well worth a visit

  • Daniele D.2 years ago

    8.0

    One has to try the bistecca Fiorintina, a great Toscan t-none steak cooked perfectly. Service is kind and gently, a true old school hosteria located in the old city centre of San Gimignano

  • Carlotta p.more than 2 years

    5.5

    Discreta

  • Crista M.more than 2 years

    2.0

    We reserved but turned out the restaurant is closed on Thursdays

  • Massimo G.more than 2 years

    10

    I am a returning customer. I found so good the menu that I decided to return. It's an unformal restaurant with a good variety of dishes at a good prices. Recommended!!

  • Massimo I.more than 2 years

    9.5

    This restaurant offers a welcome opportunity to taste the specialties of San Gimignano. It became rich for being "the city of saffron" and saffron was its gold. I had an exceptional pasta (pici) with saffron and black truffles (another specialty) and my wife had rice with saffron and cinta senese (a local pig ragout). But everything was good and very much local.

  • Clark r.more than 2 years

    10

    Absolutely superb meal in a gorgeous location. Beautiful service and a wonderful evening.

  • Harrison D.more than 2 years

    10

    Amazing service and the best plates I’ve eaten in a long time. Highly recommended !

  • Roberto S.more than 2 years

    7.5

    The food was good!!,, specially the tartuffo tagliatelle

  • - -.more than 2 years

    9.5

    We had just arrived and were looking for a nice lunch before we checked in to our hotel. We each got a pizza and a glass of house wine. Perfect. The pizza tasted great and so do the wine, although I am no wine expert. Reasonably priced as well. Very pleasant older gentleman greeted us and others and seated us. Spoke enough English to communicate well. Very welcoming.

  • - -.more than 2 years

    9.0

    We went twice. Great food, check out the 'specials' which are different from the 'tourist usual'. Definitely recommend this place

  • - -.more than 2 years

    8.0

    We liked it so much we went back a second time.

  • - -.more than 2 years

    5.0

    They forgot to bring our meal. We finally asked them where our food was and reminded them we were there to eat lunch. The food was average, but worth the hour and a half we waited. They discounted our meal by just €4.50 to compensate for forgetting our meal.

Tripadvisor reviews

Tripadvisor
831 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

Book a table

For free

Are you a restaurant owner?

Register your Restaurant

Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible

Already a Client

Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.

Download our App

  • Download from the App Store
  • Get it on Google Play
  • About
  • Loyalty program
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Are you a restaurant?
  • Privacy and Cookies Statement
  • Frequently asked questions
  • We are hiring
  • MICHELIN Guide Partnership
  • Restaurant near me

© 2026 La FourchetteSAS - All rights reserved

Promotional offers are subject to conditions displayed on the restaurant’s page. Offers on alcoholic beverages are strictly reserved for adults. Alcohol abuse is dangerous for your health. Drink with moderation.