Reviews - Trattoria i Fratellini
Reviews
9.2/10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
All reviews
10
Very good steak!!!!!!!
9.5
Steak Florentine was amazing!
10
The staff at this restaurant was very welcoming, and accommodating of my immunocompromizing issue, we were seated in a private area of the restaurant. The food was terrific, and the service outstanding!
8.5
Filet with truffle was amazing!
10
Wonderful meal in a treat of a restaurant. The staff and service was amazing!
10
great service, very friendly and welcoming
10
Great Steak, locals...would definitely recommend!
10
Food was outstanding, service was personable and wonderful. This is the second time we visited in 2025. Will def return again!
10
Very good Fiorentina
3.5
Bread thrown on table in a paper bag with no plate or any olive oil. No gluten free bread offered to my wife until requested, Potatoes were cold - and were still cold after asking them to be heated. Steak was delicious but we asked for it to be cooked a little more but seemed no different when returned. My wife felt she was being made fun of when she told the waiter that she was coeliac.
9.0
It was a great dinner! Florentine steak was delicious along with the ricotta and sage appetizer! We came for the steak and it was amazing!
9.0
The food was absolutely amazing and very reasonably priced. One older woman server was not very friendly and was quite rude but the other folks were kind and attentive. Maybe better to keep her away from customers. Overall, a wonderful experience and so nice to see the meat preparation while enjoying dinner.
10
food well. mood good. staff kind. i`m Korean. toilet clean. let`s go!!
10
Friendly local vibe, warm & inviting atmosphere, and incredible food!
10
Family neighborhood restaurant with warmth. Incredible and authentic Tuscan food and Florentine steaks. Mostly locals. A little walk from the tourist areas, but well worth it. One of the best steaks I’ve had in my life.
10
Outstanding food and service!
10
Excellent steak, wine, dessert and service!
10
This was a great place to dine. It is somewhat out of the tourist area so it is frequented by a nice mix of intrepid travelers and locals. The food from the appetizer to the end of the meal was perfect. Be sure to get the Bisteca cooked over a coal embers from a wood fire. The grill chef was both talented and attentive. The steak is presented for your inspection prior to cooking. The baked potato accompanied rhe steak and it was extraordinary.
10
high quality meat, great atmosphere
10
The food was excellent. Even if you are solo unless you don’t eat it, order the steak, the preparation was fantastic. The wine by the glass was also vey good. The ambience was very nice and the staff extremely welcoming. The tables are spaced apart so you don’t feel too crowded. A good value for the price.
10
+1An absolutely amazing meal and service. If you have the chance to experience a “T-bone” here (noting I’ve never had a “T-bone” that even comes close) then you need to do it.
10
Excellent food. Great service. Romantic setting.
9.0
Excellent food and wine. Reasonable prices. Friendly service.
2.0
Empty restaurant, poor service, and disgusting steak. The staff will give you the worst meat when you book via The Fork with a discount. We paid 85€ for only the meat, having a 50% discount because the staff said the only steak they had was a 1.89 kg steak (for 2) at price 10€/100gr. The meat was overcooked, not tasty, dry and chewy. Also there was literally no one else in the restaurant except for us, on a Friday evening at 8pm. It says a lot…
10
I was awesome
8.5
The food came out fast but the check came slow. The meat was tasty, tender, with a nice char and smoked.
10
Amazing food (excelent tartare!), perfect service- 10/10. We will visit again. :)
10
the best restaurant in Florence and the staff amazing
10
The recommended Ragu pasta was really good. And the truffle tartare was good, too
10
Everything was perfect and delicious. We ordered far too much food because the steak is tremendous, but it was worth it. The beef tartar with truffles was out of this world. The waiter was engaging and joyous. When I pulled up the location on my maps App, we debated whether it would be worth the walk. It was!
8.0
We are 2 persons, especially we have ate some amuse-bouche before the dinner, this is the first time for my husband to be Florence, we were planning to order a steak maximum 1kg, in this way we can order something else to try more plats. but the boss was refusing to give us a smaller one, he said you have to take this one of 1.4kg or nothing, finally we couldn’t finish the meet, half left, The steak is tasty, but I could be better if we can chose the weight of meet.
10
The food was great, and the staff was very welcoming and nice. I highly recommend this place for dinner when staying in Florence.
10
For an amazing and authentic Florence experience you must go here. It is off the beaten path, but so worth it. We went with our 3 kids and they loved it! Our daughter has Celiac and they were so helpful.
8.0
We had a great time and the food was very good but the waiter forgot parts of the order after upselling up on their Florentine steak (it had beed better at other restaurants) and a higher wine than we wanted so the bill really ballooned.
8.5
Steak, potatoes and fried zucchini flowers were excellent. We didn’t like the “Tuscan Tuna/Pork” appetizer. Wine and service was great.
10
Delicious meal and friendly atmosphere! Highly recommend this amazing place.
8.5
The florentine steak was amazing! Great flavor and cooked perfectly. We were the only people in the restaurant which was a little odd but the food was very good!
10
We had a fabulous tasting meal and had the owner personally making sure everything was just right. They even have a kids menu! Perfect cap to our time in Florence
10
An absolute must go place for a proper fiorentina steak. Nice and cozy, you see first hand the cut of the beef and the food is prepared perfectly. Worth to go and worth to come back for more
10
From the food to the service, everything was absolutely first class.
Tripadvisor reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Book a table
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.