Hjortur H. • 3 reviews

October 8, 2025

10/10

Absolutely amazing food, we had a mix of fish plates. Lovely. The staff is great and wow the environment is magical. Highly recommend

likeReport

arturo m. • 1 review

September 25, 2025

9.5/10

The service is excellent, and the location makes it an outstanding choice.

likeReport

valerie y. • 1 review

August 15, 2025

10/10

The location of the restaurant is magnificent. On the water where you can jump off for a swim. We wanted a change from busy Positano and caught a water taxi to Praiano. We had a beautiful lunch and it was memorable

likeReport

Louise C. • 3 reviews

August 14, 2025

10/10

Atmospheric setting, like a scene from The Talented Mr Ripley.

likeReport

Brian S. • 1 review

July 12, 2025

10/10

Lovely setting and great service

likeReport

Neela P. • 1 review

May 18, 2025

9.5/10

Amazing venue with a history

likeReport

Mike G. • 6 reviews

May 13, 2025

10/10

The view was astonishing and the food was delicious. Sitting right on the water by the port in the moonlight was amazing and the service and staff are so kind and amazing.

likeReport

Tambra F. • 1 review

May 13, 2025

10/10

I celebrated my 60th birthday there, it was amazing and would highly recommend the Past with Lobster!!!!

likeReport

Terry A. • 3 reviews

April 23, 2025

10/10

Absolutely beautiful view. Delicious food and excellent service. We highly recommend

likeReport

Dena K. • 1 review

October 8, 2024

10/10

Reno and his stuff was exceptional!!

likeReport

Michael B. • 1 review

October 6, 2024

10/10

The service was incredible. The staff takes special care to ensure a wonderful experience. The food was delicious. We had the Eggplant parmigiana, Octopus, beef carpaccio, caprese salad with culatello ham and finished off with their homemade tiramisu! The ambiance was breathtaking. We sat off the rocks right next to the sea. Perfect evening.

likeReport

Yoanny I. • 1 review

October 7, 2024

9/10

The food nothing special, good views and good vibes

likeReport

Corky T. • 2 reviews

September 14, 2024

10/10

We had the most wonderful time. The venue is spectacular. The staff was super friendly. The food was cooked to perfection. We had the grilled Seabass and it just melted in your mouth. We got there just before sunset and it was gorgeous and the view just kept getting better and better.

likeReport

Leonard U. • 1 review

September 10, 2024

10/10

An evening at Il Pirata is enchanting. The lovely grotto bar and tables terraced a few feet above the water create a beguiling ambience. The food and service is superlative. Truly one of my finest dining experiences!

likeReport

Tugce D. • 2 reviews

August 28, 2024

10/10

The food was delicious. The stuff was welcoming. The view was stunning. Everything about this place was wonderful.

likeReport

Cátia M. • 1 review

July 23, 2024

4/10

The food was good, but the service was not great.

likeReport

Edward T. • 8 reviews

July 16, 2024

10/10

Great food, ambiance and service with wonderful views of the Amalfi Coast. A great dining experience.

likeReport

David V. • 4 reviews

July 2, 2024

9/10

Ambience = great. Service was very attentive and friendly. Food quality 4/5. Good, not amazing.

likeReport

Fabiana M. • 3 reviews

July 1, 2024

10/10

Everything was absolutely amazing! The view is breathtaking , the food top quality and also we would like to thank the staff that made our night special!

likeReport

Kristine C. • 4 reviews

June 23, 2024

8.5/10

+2

My daughters and I enjoyed dinner here during a week’s long stay in Praiano. The location is lovely. However, we were seated at a table that gave a direct view to the kitchen from one side and a view of a prep cart from the other side (rather than a direct view of the water). I asked to be moved to another table that overlooked the water but was informed that the manager determined seating and we weren’t able to move (yes, I made reservations weeks before our trip). My daughter’s steak was delicious but my pasta with fish was average. The desserts were yummy but overall the meal was the most expensive of our journey. The bill also indicated “service fee not included” which was the only time we received such a message. Tips are not common in Italy, so it seemed like a money grab (and yes, I always leave tips but don’t like being told to do so).

likeReport