Teatro44

Robert B. • 1 review

July 3, 2025

9.5/10

The vibe was sophisticated and relaxed. The menu was simple but varied and intriguing. The service was attentive, friendly and unobtrusive. The wine list had lots of great options - we settled on a delicious Tuscan Chianti.

likeReport

Sabrina C. • 1 review

June 1, 2025

9.5/10

A Hidden Gem in the Heart of Taormina Tucked away on one of Taormina’s charming narrow streets, this quiet, elegant restaurant was an unforgettable find. We opted for the 5-course tasting menu, and from the very first bite, it was clear we were in for something special. Each dish was a masterpiece—meticulously crafted, beautifully plated, and infused with its own distinct, enchanting aroma. The progression of flavors felt like a carefully composed symphony, with every course offering something unique yet harmonious. The attention to detail was remarkable, and the pacing allowed us to truly savor each moment. The setting itself added to the magic—intimate and serene, a welcome contrast to the busy main streets. It felt like a secret, one we were lucky to stumble upon. This was more than a meal; it was an experience. A perfect blend of Sicilian tradition, creative flair, and heartfelt hospitality. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a refined and memorable evening in Taormina.

likeReport

Teatro44 • Owner

Thank you from the bottom of our hearts for such a thoughtful and gracious review. Knowing that every dish, every aroma, and every detail contributed to creating a memorable experience for you is the greatest reward we could hope for. Your words reflect exactly what we strive to offer each evening: care, harmony, and authenticity. And just as Teatro44 felt like a hidden gem you were lucky to discover, please know that for us, it was just as special to welcome you and share this little secret corner of Taormina with you.

Demet O. • 1 review

April 30, 2025

10/10

Amazing food and service. The only problem is eating too much.

likeReport

Antonio D. • 3 reviews

November 19, 2024

10/10

During my visit to Taormina, I had one of the most exceptional dinners I've ever experienced. The restaurant masterfully blends traditional cuisine with a modern twist, making it a must-visit destination. The atmosphere is unparalleled, and the extensive wine selection adds to the overall experience. This place is definitely on track to earn a Michelin star in the near future.

likeReport

Liz-Tone T. • 2 reviews

November 5, 2024

4/10

we were welcomed nice, the menu looked good but the food in 5 course menu was bad, especially the fishsoup. This was a disappointment. We had higher expectations, that were not fulfilled. The wine we chose was good. It was cold in the restaurant because the outdoor was open all the time. Cigarette smoke entered the restaurant from time to time, not nice.

likeReport

Joey L. • 3 reviews

October 23, 2024

9.5/10

Made a reservation last minute and went in slightly blind to the menu. Very impressed with the quality of food. Unsure what people expect from service staff, was aligned with my expectations. It is a seafood-driven menu with a few non seafood options. This is not a basic tourist spot. If you want a thoughtfully curated menu with a solid wine list, this is your spot. Would absolutely return. We ordered: Cod croquettes, Gnochetti, Swordfish Wellington (WOW), coconut mousse dessert. Red wine and received a wonderful glass of Gulfi Rossojbleo.

likeReport

Eileen M. • 1 review

September 20, 2024

10/10

Run, don’t walk to try out Teatro44. It’s spectacular… amazing food and wonderful, attentive service. I understood from our concierge that it’s fairly new which is possibly why it wasn’t busy (also they didn’t have a website when I booked.) It’s not going to take long before it’s no longer a secret gem. It was fantastic.

1Report

Steve R. • 1 review

September 23, 2024

8/10

The food was excellent. Creative and delicious. The waiter was not interested at all and did not provide any conversation or explanation of the dishes. The cooks were very busy. We waited way too long for our main course. The waiter gave no response or indication when it will arrive. They were short on cooks. Really enjoyed the food.

likeReport

Joseph I. • 1 review

September 4, 2024

9.5/10

The ingredients and service were phenomenal. Two exciting chefs that should work towards a little more balance of the amazing flavors they’ve pieced together. Would go back for seconds 10/10 times. The langoustine carpaccio was like butter. Multiple “wows”.

likeReport

Christer M. • 1 review

July 31, 2024

10/10

Fantastic food with surprising combinations of ingredients that made the experience one of the best we ever had.

likeReport

Teatro44 • Owner

Dear Christer, thank you for your kind words. We are so glad you and your family spent a nice experience at Teatro 44. Thank you for coming a second time, hope there will be a third if you ever come back in Taormina. See you soon :)

Nancy M. • 1 review

July 26, 2024

8.5/10

The food in this restaurant was incredible but for some reason it was quite empty so lacked atmosphere. I have no idea why people are not flocking to eat in here, it is off the main drag and so does not have the footfall but the food was so good should be rammed! I would definitely recommend it and would jump at the chance to eat in here again.

likeReport

Yuliya Z. • 1 review

July 24, 2024

10/10

It was perfect experience! The food is very good! The service on high level. The desert is on top!

likeReport

Mark L. • 2 reviews

July 8, 2024

6/10

We choose this restaurant based on the positive feedback from Fork Customers. We arrived a little early to an empty restaurant. We asked for the house wines but they were out, immediately hiking up the price of the wine. The waiter made us up a starter of oysters, carpaccio of fish and a shrimp tartar. Tasty. Mains were all good but my son, asked for his steak to come without the Parmigiano as he doesn't like cheese. This was clearly lost in translation as the steak was served completely by itself without mash or vegetables. More customers did arrive but the atmosphere remained stilted. Food was good but expensive. Would not go back.

likeReport

James B. • 3 reviews

June 30, 2024

9.5/10

The tasting menu was in the amazing category. Service was lovely. We got there a bit early when it was quiet to start with - but livened up later - and would recommend booking a bit later. Great value for the quality.

likeReport

Sergio V. • 2 reviews

June 23, 2024

8.5/10

Excellent food with very attractive presentations. The menu is very interesting with some innovative touches that give each dish an extra dimension. The only negative note was the very loud local musical group that came to play music for the tables outside- the volume was way too loud and disturbed guests inside who just wanted to have a peaceful conversation .

likeReport

Chris B. • 2 reviews

June 11, 2024

9.5/10

Food was amazing. The owner was very attentive and informative. Not the least overbearing. Made for a lovely evening. Quite expensive but hey. Also the jazz music was the teeniest bit loud and was on a loop of about four songs all night. The food was the reason we made the Everest-like trip and it was worth the effort. Overall, very good indeed.

likeReport

Martin M. • 3 reviews

June 1, 2024

10/10

Taormina is full of "me too" restaurants. Some are very good, but they are not especially creative. T44 is not like that. They try stuff and the results are often very good. These folks think like artists, not just like chefs -- and you know it the moment you walk in. So yes -- give it a try.

likeReport

Peter O. • 1 review

May 9, 2024

10/10

Had a great 5-course chefs menu dinner, all composed around a superb Etna white wine. Teatro44 is a quiet and cozy oasis just a little away from the overcrowded tourist areas and in a class of itself. This was our last evening in Sicily before flying back to Germany and a perfect “last-vacation-day -special-dinner”! Thank you for the excellent food and superb service! 🙏

likeReport

Robert M. • 9 reviews

May 9, 2024

9/10

the ambience of the restaurant was 5 star. The service was excellent. We ordered their steak main dish and it was very fatty. the pasta dish was good but not 5 star.

likeReport

Martin V. • 1 review

November 4, 2023

5/10

Small restaurant. Very slow service.

likeReport