Trattoria dall'Oste Via Alamanni

Kwangwon S. • 1 review

September 12, 2025

2/10

We decided to book this restaurant because it came highly recommended by a well-known Italian in Korea, but unfortunately, our experience was very disappointing. Despite having a reservation, we had to wait over an hour for our food. The service throughout the evening was unfriendly and unprofessional — even when we asked simple questions about the dishes, the staff were unhelpful and dismissive. To make matters worse, there was no prior explanation that set menus and wine are excluded from TheFork reservation discount. In the end, we only received a 20% discount on an additional sauce, which felt misleading and unfair. We chose this restaurant to celebrate a special anniversary, but sadly it left us with disappointment instead of a memorable experience.

likeReport

Francesco M. • 2 reviews

September 8, 2025

6.5/10

Medium quality meat, small portions. Personnel nice and gentle, service fast.

likeReport

Dave C. • 1 review

September 8, 2025

10/10

Excellent food, great atmosphere.

likeReport

minju j. • 1 review

September 5, 2025

10/10

I had a wonderful dining experience thanks to Manager Lee. The food was delicious and I felt genuinely happy throughout my visit.

likeReport

Janina C. • 1 review

September 6, 2025

10/10

Amazing dinner

likeReport

YONGSUNG N. • 1 review

August 31, 2025

10/10

Food&Service

likeReport

Sharon B. • 1 review

September 1, 2025

8/10

Taratar 8.5/10 Carbonara 6.5/10 Bone in 1.2kg ribeye medium 7.8/10 Wine 8/10 Service 9.5/10 Ambience 5/10

likeReport

WS L. • 1 review

August 28, 2025

10/10

The T-bone stake was so amazing!

likeReport

Hassard H. • 2 reviews

August 19, 2025

7.5/10

Right opposite the main station. Very friendly staff, but despite a reservation we had to wait on the street for a good 5 minutes (with a glass of presseco, on the house). A good menu, but I went away disappointed. I felt what I had lacked seasoning and taste and was frankly quite bland, perhaps my choices were poor or maybe my taste buds are spoiled as we had fantastic meal the night before else where in Florence and I had high expectations.

likeReport

Samantha S. • 1 review

August 14, 2025

3/10

Do not recommend. Service was almost nonexistent. It took the server over 30 minutes to get to the table the a first time. Twenty more minutes went by and drink had not arrived at the table. When the food arrived it was just not good, the milanesse was more fat than meat. Of course we were also unable to find the server and had to pay at the entrance with the host.

likeReport

kevin T. • 8 reviews

July 28, 2025

6/10

I originally booked for 2:30 but I was late for 25 minutes. I had emailed The Fork beforehand and asked if they can contact the restaurant to hold my spot or change it for a few minutes later. My international phone card was having trouble contacting them but I did email them of my lateness. I was marked as a no show unfortunately but I rebooked on the spot and got another spot for %30 discount so I’m happy about that. We didn’t get bread with the bistecca steak but the staff seemed so fed up with me and my party, probably for being late and then we didn’t bother to ask them for any. Maybe next time!

likeReport

Kelly R. • 1 review

July 26, 2025

10/10

Our server provided excellent recommendations. The food was wonderful!

likeReport

방영 윤. • 1 review

July 21, 2025

10/10

gooooood!!!!!

likeReport

Michael G. • 1 review

July 19, 2025

9/10

The food was perfectly traditional and delicious... I will most definitely return to Trattoria dall'Oste Via Alamanni on my next visit to Florence!

likeReport

Laura C. • 3 reviews

July 23, 2025

7/10

Service could be better. Took a while to get the order. No cheese was offered with the risotto.

likeReport

Fu q. • 2 reviews

July 21, 2025

10/10

It is very delicious!

likeReport

PEI-YING L. • 2 reviews

July 17, 2025

10/10

The wonderful dinner with all my friends 🧡

likeReport

Dian Y. • 2 reviews

July 9, 2025

6/10

We had the florentine steak, the boar meat pasta, and the chicken liver appetizer. All were under flavoured. The steak cut was filled with ligaments and very chewy. I personally found the cooking of the steak fine. Then the liver had no flavour. The boar meat pasta had no salt whatsoever. There were better versions of these dishes we had at other Florence resturants. They also asked for a tip after wards. Our waiter was very friendly. There was a long line so make sure to reserve if you want to come here.

likeReport

Vangie K. • 1 review

July 7, 2025

6.5/10

quite commercial. beef is okay

likeReport

Dede A. • 1 review

July 7, 2025

4/10

Food was mediocre, staff was unfriendly. Will not recommend

likeReport