Trattoria dall'Oste BISTECCA ALLA FIORENTINA
Reviews
8.9of 10
Ratings and reviews can only be left by guests who have booked with TheFork.
Kate M. • 1 review
November 17, 2024
6.5/10How does this place rack up rave reviews? Did I wander into a parallel dimension where the food is Michelin-starred and the service divine? My experience felt more like sitting at the kids’ table at Thanksgiving—if nobody remembered to bring me food. The waiter appeared promptly, took my order—truffle pasta, steak ai funghi—and vanished like a magician. The pasta arrived so fast it seemed preordained. It was good, not transcendent. I ate half, saving room for the steak I imagined as a rustic marvel. And then… I waited. Time stretched as I watched others dine and depart. My steak remained a mirage. The waiter resurfaced after 45 minutes. I mentioned my missing steak; he smiled and cleared the table. Eventually, I went to pay and explained, politely, what had happened. They nodded with the kind of detachment reserved for complaints. After all, when you're drowning in rave reviews, one steak is forgotten as quickly as it's served (or not, in my case).
Joseph K. • 2 reviews
November 11, 2024
10/10good
Hsiu-Hsiang Y. • 1 review
November 4, 2024
9.5/10The beef is the most tender and juicy we’ve ever had. Extremely delicious! Worth a visit !
zhiqing Z. • 1 review
November 2, 2024
10/10The sever was really nice，the food good as well！
marco k. • 2 reviews
November 3, 2024
10/10greatful memory
Gail V. • 1 review
October 31, 2024
10/10We are from New York and came back to Florence and had a Florentine steak - wow!!! So fresh , never ate a steak that delicious. Highly recommend and we will go back again soon I hope …. Very welcoming 🩷
jang k. • 1 review
October 28, 2024
8/10good
呈佑 蔡. • 1 review
October 27, 2024
6/10The cut of the T-bone steak, its fat distribution, and doneness were inconsistent. I ended up with a piece that was mostly fat and cooked to medium-rare, which tasted a bit unpleasant.
Rodrigo N. • 1 review
October 20, 2024
4/10I don't know if all locations are the same, but the one we went to (by train station) was extremely over crowed, stuffy and service was very bad. Servers looked miserable, not very knowledgeable and just plain out indifferent. The wine was good ($60 bottle) but the steak Florentine (their top steak) was nothing to write home about. Very bland, seemed unseasoned, and I mean just on a basic salt level! I am from Chile and have had many open flame prepared meats and steaks, this was not uneatable but definitely at the bottom of the barrel in my experience and nowhere near worth the price. Maybe try another cut if you want to give it a go but I'd recommend going elsewhere.
Thodoris C. • 1 review
October 22, 2024
10/10The food and the price was soooo good!
David S. • 5 reviews
October 21, 2024
8.5/10The food was very good, but I was not thrilled by the service (and upselling attempts): * Would you like a different cut of beef instead of the French beef? The waiter pointed at the menu which showed prices for different items, but I couldn't tell if they were additional charges (of more than the base amount) or would be the total (in which case they were only a few Euros more than the base and I might have tried one). * They were "out" of the Chianti Classico I ordered but conveniently had a Chianti Classico Reserva (from a different provider) for just 15 Euros more. I decided to go with the Reserva and it was good, but I find it hard to believe that they didn't have a Classico available. * There was a mysterious charge for a "petite aqua" on our bill (we'd ordered a large water, which was on the bill, too). The cashier removed it when I pointed it out. They honored the 20% discount without my having to ask for it. Reservations were essential - it was full by 7pm.
Yiyan Z. • 1 review
October 21, 2024
10/10I had a fantastic dining experience at this restaurant! The reservation on The Fork was very convenient with a 30% discount by booking in advance. T-bone steak is so so delicious—tender, juicy, and highly recommended. Another must-try is their signature black truffle pasta; it was rich, flavorful, and the best I’ve had in Italy!!! Overall, both the service and the quality of the dishes were excellent. I will definitely be coming back!
Suzanne A. • 1 review
October 16, 2024
10/10Delicious
Jessa Mae M. • 1 review
October 16, 2024
9.5/10The Fiorentina steak is perfect! Truly one of a kind. Service was also great and they got us a free dessert for my husband’s birthday. Will definitely recommend to visit Trattoria Dall’ Oste when in Florence.
Rob N. • 1 review
October 8, 2024
6.5/10Ambiance was very nice. For a 'high end' restaurant in Italy, the food was pretty marginal. Pasta (not fresh) was severely undercooked (crunchy), the steak was very average. Sequencing of courses was not good. We had 4 people, 2 were service their primary course and 15 minutes later the other 2 received theirs. One diner ended up eating his last course while the other 3 watched. Server seemed irritated when we didn't order fast enough - we were catching up with friends over a glass of wine. Service went downhill after that. Over all, a marginal experience...
Anju I. • 1 review
October 9, 2024
10/10Great food, great service. We went from Canada and definitely were not disappointed! Will visit Trattoria dall’Oste every time we’re in Florence.
Victoria R. • 1 review
October 12, 2024
4/10Dis’s appointment
Shane Kheren R. • 1 review
October 5, 2024
10/10The steak was really good. It was well seasoned and tender. I will be back
Armen K. • 1 review
October 7, 2024
9.5/10the stake was unforgettinle!
Sharon H. • 8 reviews
October 7, 2024
9/10The food was good.. service was prompt and staff were polite. restaurant is very popular so u definitely have to make a reservation
Tripadvisor reviews
Location
More details
About this restaurant
Frequently Asked Questions
Trattoria dall'Oste BISTECCA ALLA FIORENTINA
Book a table for
Restaurants around Trattoria dall'Oste BISTECCA ALLA FIORENTINA
Other restaurants in Florence that you may like
Are you a restaurant owner?
Register your Restaurant
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Already a Client
Log in to TheFork Manager and contact us by Chat.